Education and the State

State control of all schools in not outlandish, as Liam McNally asserts. It is necessary.

“The question is what is education for? Answers fall into two camps - social reproduction or social change.”

John Mulloy

IN his ‘De Facto’ column of June 23, Liamy McNally asserts that State control of all schools would be ‘simply outlandish’. While completely agreeing with his denunciation of both past and ongoing failures by the State and organisations such as the ISPCC, I would argue that, far from being outlandish, such a development is necessary if this country is ever to mature into a fully-functioning constitutional democracy.

The problem for the Catholic Church is that there is no room in a modern democracy for two ‘states’. Following Augustine, the medieval Church claimed both temporal and spiritual power (‘two swords in one sheath’), and saw the secular state as merely an enforcer of religious coercion. This was first challenged in the 14th century, with early demands for secular sovereignty. Further developments in the Reformation led to capitalism and ultimately a constitutional democratic system. The linking of nationalism and Catholicism in Irish politics in the 19th century culminated in the idea of creating the “world’s working model of Catholic philosophy”, through a ‘conservative revolution’, cancelling capitalism and restoring the ‘Old Order’.

‘Rerum Novarum’, the 1891 Encyclical of Pope Leo XIII, asserted the natural inequality of man and denounced all forms of socialism. In particular, “to suffer and endure” was seen as “the lot of humanity.”  This, according to “What Sinn Fein Stands For’ (De Blacam, 1921), was “the justification for Order, Authority and Obedience, by which Catholic theory stands or falls. The wisest laws will often have some unjust incidence, and Catholic doctrine demands that in these cases they be loyally obeyed. Order demands sacrifice, and sacrifice is the human lot”. Thus the ideal was a Catholic theocracy – much like the demands of Islamic fundamentalists today.

Due to this dogma of obedience, the Church became not only autonomous from the new Irish State but able to dominate it, shaping future generations through its control over the education system.  Irish politics in the new State was effectively a return to the Augustinian ideal, where the State existed to support the Church’s mission. The Church was literally beyond the law, because, following Augustine, the law was a human creation while the Church was a divine creation. As loyal Catholics, it was the duty of most of the population – including politicians, civil servants and ISPCC ‘cruelty men’ - to unquestioningly obey the Church, inevitably leading to abuse.

The key question is what is education for? Answers to this fall into two camps - social reproduction or social change. Traditional Catholic education in Ireland was about replacing the stock of Catholics, fully forming them in the orthodox beliefs of the faith - a social reproduction model. By contrast, current Irish education is based on preparing students to compete in the new ‘knowledge economy’ - a social change model. Since the Cold War, the market-state has emerged, replacing the old nation-state. The market-state’s purpose is to maximise the economic opportunity of its citizens. Ireland, for good or ill, has adopted this model, and this has led to the new role for education, now seen as central to improving the status of the economy as a whole.

This change also means that there has been a fundamental shift in the relationship between Church and State in Ireland. As we develop a fully-functioning constitutional democracy, there is no longer room for the power previously claimed by the Church. As a result, the Church will inevitably be forced to withdraw from the education system, as the purpose of education in the country has changed. The Church itself will need to find an answer to the most difficult question of what its role is to be in this emerging new society – is it a competitor to State power, a civil society organisation or should it be purely part of people’s private lives?  While I agree with Mr McNally about the inadequacies of the State both past and present, this fundamental shift in the direction of Irish politics means that state control of education, far from being outlandish, is rapidly becoming both necessary and inevitable. It is then up to us to demand the best possible education for all our children.

John Mulloy lives in Knockrooskey, Westport.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice