Driver cleared of breaking rest period regulations

A courier was cleared of breaking rest period regulations after the judge ruled that the case was based on hearsay evidence.

Driver cleared of breaking rest period regulations

A COURIER who was being prosecuted for excessive daily driving while travelling from Ballina to Dublin had all the charges dismissed after a District Court judge said the basis of the case was all hearsay evidence.

Mr Frank Kelly of Iceford, Quay Road, Ballina, was charged with excessive daily driving on a number of occasions when driving from Ballina to Dublin in 2006 and 2007. Mr Luke O’Toole, a transport officer with the Department of Transport, explained that on April 11, 2007, he met by appointment with Ms Hillary Barins at the Department of Transport offices to inspect tachographs charts.

He explained that he cautioned her after noticing infringements in the charts, and she informed him that she and her husband, Frank Kelly, operated a haulage business. He said she told him that while the business was in her name, they operated it together.

Mr O’Toole told the court that the daily driving period restriction was nine hours, which may be extended to ten hours twice a week, and the daily required rest was eleven hours. He explained that on seven occasions in 2006 and 2007, the tachograph of the vehicle driven by Mr Kelly showed he did not comply with these regulations.

He explained that all the journeys for Mr Kelly were from Ballina to Drogheda and from Drogheda to Dublin Port where he would rest before returning back to Ballina. Mr O’Toole said that the rest periods varied from three hours to seven hours and 40 minutes. He said that Ms Barins said she was aware of the legislation and admitted they had problems with that route and were no longer doing it.

Mr O’Toole said he was not sure why there was a delay in the prosecution but felt it may have been because of the decentralisation process which resulted in all the files being transported from Dublin to Loughrea. He added that legislation allowed for a two-year window before prosecution.

Under questioning from Mr Evan O’Dwyer, solicitor for the defendant, Mr O’Toole admitted that the entire prosecution was on the basis of the information from Ms Barins and the tachograph. He said that he had not read the notes he took from Ms Barins back over to her and she had not signed anything to indicate what she said to him was accurate. Mr O’Dwyer asked Mr O’Toole if it would have been prudent of him to follow up on his findings and talk to Mr Kelly who was being prosecuted.

Mr O’Toole said he has had 20 years experience as an official in the Department and had been given training on legal expertise and it was never a requirement for anyone to sign notes he had taken.

Mr O’Dwyer said that a large bulk of the evidence in the case was based on information given verbally by a person who was not a state witness and this was hearsay evidence. He added that he was not satisfied that Ms Barins was informed that the information she gave would form part of the case against Mr Kelly and in criminal prosecutions any statement would have to be read over and signed.

Judge Mary Devins said she had heard no independent evidence connecting Mr Kelly with the vehicle, adding that in her view the case was based on hearsay. She dismissed all matters.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice