’Devastation’ at death probe outcome


THE family and next-door neighbour of the Erris farmer, John Gaughan, who was found dead in suspicious circumstances last year, have expressed their disappointment that the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) elected not to proceed with a criminal case on the matter.
Gaughan family ‘devastated’ at outcome of death probe
DPP directions questioned as inquest hears admission that neighbour ran over John Gaughan
Anna-Marie Flynn
THE family and next-door neighbour of the Erris farmer, John Gaughan (pictured), who was found dead in suspicious circumstances last year, have expressed their disappointment that the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) elected not to proceed with a criminal case on the matter.
At an inquest held in Ballina courthouse last week, a jury returned a verdict of accidental death caused by massive crush injuries to the body of the 72-year-old bachelor. The injuries were as a result of an accident on March 10, 2007 outside Mr Gaughan’s home at Glosh, Blacksod.
At the inquest, a statement given to the Gardaí by Michael Gerard Keane, known locally as Jed Keane, included an admission that he ran over the deceased with a transit van after leaving him home from a local pub. Mr Keane refused to sign the statement at the inquest but told the family that while he did not recall hitting anything at all on the night, he accepted that he must have killed John Gaughan.
Coroner for north Mayo, Dr Eleanor Fitzgerald, said that while the Gardaí had ‘left no stone unturned’ in an extensive investigation, no proceedings had been brought to date.
Speaking to The Mayo News yesterday (Monday), Theresa Boyle, sister of the late Mr Gaughan, said the family were too upset to speak at length on the issue, but stated: “As a family we are completely and totally devastated at the outcome.”
Next-door neighbour Willie Meenaghan, who found the body of his life-long friend lying crossways in a pool of blood in the deceased’s driveway, said the community was shocked by what it heard at the inquest.
He refuted the verdict reached by the jurors that Mr Gaughan’s death was ‘an accident’. “All I heard [at the inquest] was talk of people going on about drinking and how John was drunk. Why isn’t there someone in jail over this whole thing?” he said.
Mr Meenaghan said he could not speak for the Gaughan family but said that the relatives and friends ‘are bound to be very unhappy’ about the decision of the DPP not to prosecute. “They couldn’t be happy about this,” he said. “I cannot make head nor tail of why the course of justice has not been carried out.”
A Garda spokesman said a very thorough investigation took place. “Over 150 statements were taken and experts from the technical bureau travelled from Dublin to investigate the scene, as did the forensic unit. A file was prepared and submitted to the DPP on the matter. The DPP elected not to issue any further proceedings.”
A file was submitted to the DPP by gardaí in June 2007, following a three-month investigation. The DPP direction not to prosecute was returned in August 2007. The Mayo News understands that the lengthy delay in holding an inquest was due to a requested review of the DPP’s initial decision.
Driver does not recall killing man
A DRIVER who accidentally killed a 72-year-old farmer after leaving him home from the local pub, but has no recollection of the incident, told an inquest last week: “There isn’t a minute when I don’t think about the heartache I have caused a family.”
Michael Gerard Keane, known locally as Jed Keane, of Glosh, Blacksod, addressed the coroner’s court at the inquest into the death of John Martin Frank Gaughan, Glosh, Blacksod, who was found dead outside his own home on March 11, 2007.
Referring to the deceased as a ‘great friend’, Mr Keane said: “I would rather be locked up than have that family think I left a good friend to die.”
After considering the statements of State Pathologist, Dr Marie Cassidy, 17 witnesses and forensic scientists, taken from an extensive investigation that included 150 statements, a jury of five men and one woman returned a verdict of accidental death.
Coroner for north Mayo, Dr Eleanor Fitzgerald, heard that John Gaughan was drinking in O’Raghallaigh’s Pub, Binghamstown, on Saturday, March 10, 2007 from about midday before being left home by Jed Keane some time after 9.30pm.
Next-door neighbour, William Meenaghan, found the body of Mr Gaughan halfway up the deceased’s driveway the next morning, March 11.
Mr Meenaghan said he knew when he saw the body of John Gaughan lying crossways on the drive, slumped forward in a pool of blood, that his neighbour was dead. He described the body as like ‘a sheet of ice’. Jed Keane arrived at the scene at 1.15pm and told gardaí he left Mr Gaughan home the previous night.
Part-time fisherman, Mr Keane, then 25 years old, made his first statement on the matter on March 13, when he said he was driving a white transit van, owned by a friend, on the night in question. He gave evidence of drinking in The Loft in Ballina, The Corner House in Belmullet and then O’Raghallaigh’s Pub, Binghamstown. After socialising with Mr Gaughan, he left him home and said as far as he was concerned the deceased went into his house after the outside sensor light went off.
In a second statement, made by Jed Keane on March 14, he said when he drove back down Mr Gaughan’s driveway he felt the van ‘rise on something, but after a slight throttle, it came down again’. Mr Keane said he knew it must have been John Gaughan, as ‘realistically, it could not have been anything else’.
Stating he was ‘pure scared’ of looking back, he said: “I was more afraid to look back, not of what I had done, but of what I might see.” The next day, a friend rang Jed Keane to tell him John Gaughan was found dead outside his home, a ‘phone-call he described as ‘confirming his worst fears’.
When both statements were read out by Superintendent Frank Walsh at the inquest in Ballina Courthouse last week, Jed Keane refused to sign the second statement, stating he only made an admission to gardaí after he saw the ‘heartache’ that was being caused to his family throughout the investigation.
He refuted details of his second statement saying that he made his admission to ‘get out’ of the interrogative questioning, but, in reality, did not recall hitting anything at all with his vehicle.
“That statement is plainly saying I know I left a man to die, when I know I did not,” he told the court, before adding: “I know the accident happened and I know I was the only person in possession of the keys of the van. I had a lot of drink taken and I know it.”
In evidence, Dr Marie Cassidy said there were two to three areas of blood staining near the body, one containing some hair; irregular tears on the clothing; and the face was covered in blood.
Dr Cassidy outlined multiple injuries to the body, including grazes on the face and forehead; a large graze on the right side of his skull where there was hair loss; a serious crush injury to the chest and rib cage where the right side of the chest had caved in; spinal fracture; laceration of liver; fracture of left shoulder joints and bruising to the arms and shins.
She said the death was due to crush asphyxia due to vehicular trauma, consistent with an injury caused by the wheel of a vehicle rolling across the chest, with the right shin bruising most likely caused by a bumper of a vehicle.
The hair missing from the area at the back of the head indicated the body was dragged along the ground when his clothing got caught underneath the vehicle.
Forensic evidence revealed that DNA results of the deceased correlated with the profile present in the diesel tank of the transit van driven by Jed Keane, with a one in one thousand million chance that this could be the profile of someone other than John Gaughan.
Asking the jury to take due consideration of the ‘complicated and serious’ evidence, the coroner said whether he was within the legal limit or not, six to eight alcohol units were consumed by Jed Keane on the night, and a road traffic incident followed in which the deceased suffered a fatal crush injury.
After seven minutes’ deliberation, the foreman of the jury delivered a verdict of accidental death, in what he called ‘a most unfortunate’ incident.
Dr Fitzgerald said it was a tragic case where alcohol played a ‘major factor’. She sympathised with the family of the late John Gaughan but noted Mr Keane will carry the burden of the death.
Superintendent Walsh, on behalf of An Garda Síochána, expressed his sympathy to the family and friends of the deceased.
A great friend remembered
IN a sentence that evoked a snapshot of a community spirit that has since been broken by tragedy, Michael Kilcoyne, described his friend, John Gaughan’s last hours on earth: “Everyone was so happy at that time. It was a long day in the pub and everyone was in good form.”
Michael Kilcoyne, Bayview, Belmullet, was speaking at the inquest into the death of popular local, John Gaughan, Glosh, last week.
He said he went into O’Raghallaigh’s Pub, Binghamstown at around 11.15 on Saturday morning, March 10, 2007. About ten minutes later, John Gaughan came in.
He gave a typical account of men in a bar on a Saturday afternoon, joking and laughing. “The craic was good,” he said. He talked of John Gaughan offering to buy him a drink and how he joked in response that he couldn’t afford it; a move which prompted John Gaughan to produce a roll of cash. “A moth flew out of the money and that caused even more of a laugh and joke,” he said.
But the community was set to collapse in sadness just a few hours later, following the discovery of the body of John Gaughan, in what gardaí described as ‘suspicious circumstances’.
The local community was left in shock. At his funeral Mass on March 15, Fr Michael Harrison referred to him as ‘a Good Samaritan’ and told a congregation that flowed into the confines of Our Lady of Lourdes church grounds, that people were numbed and traumatised by the tragedy.
Immediately after his death, neighbour John Meenaghan, said of his life-long friend: “He’d do anything for you if you were in trouble, that’s the way John was and if you asked him to go to America on a boat with you he’d go, or any place.”
A year-and-a-half later the sorrow is still palpable. The neighbours still in shock. The family still mourning. And everyone misses John.
Speaking yesterday (Monday) his sister Theresa told The Mayo News of a man with a good word for all. “John was really larger than life. He was just so so special to all of us. We’re lost without him,” she said. She spoke of the ‘complete and utter devastation’ that has been compounded by a complex investigation, case and inquest.
In Glosh, his presence is notably absent every single minute of every day. Next-door neighbour, Willie Meenaghan, said he knew John Gaughan since the 1930s – all his life. They were childhood friends who lived life and grew from boys to men together. “We were friends forever, since we were in school together and even before that. We did everything together.”
Mr Meenaghan said the community is no longer the same; it has lost its shining light. “Everyone misses John. I miss him every single day. He was so well-known in the area; a great neighbour who would do anything for anyone. He was a hard worker and someone who could have a great chat with anyone.”
Locals remember his role in the windswept village on the tip of the Mullet peninsula. Central to the 1980s development of the Elly/Blacksod water scheme, John would leave his Christmas dinner to ensure the path of the water across the hill to the families in the area. He was a cornerstone of a community, whose heart has been ripped out by his passing.
Statement after statement read out at last week’s inquiry into his tragic death recalled the late John Gaughan, a man rarely seen without his beige baseball cap, as a ‘man with always a good word to say’, ‘someone who was very obliging’, ‘a great friend’, ‘a person you could set your watch to’ and ‘a lovely neighbour’. A man who will not be forgotten.