Cutbacks putting ’lives at risk’

THE HSE have been accused of putting people’s lives at risk after it emerged that savings of €100,000 a month in November and December will have to be made to the ambulance service in Mayo.

Cutbacks putting ‘lives at risk’

Cancer patient misses hospital appointment, while Order of Malta called on to bring patient home from hospital

Anton McNulty

THE HSE have been accused of putting people’s lives at risk after it emerged that savings of €100,000 a month in November and December will have to be made to the ambulance service in Mayo.

In an internal memo seen by The Mayo News, Mr Ray Bonar, Chief Ambulance Officer with HSE West, told colleagues that the budgetary position within the ambulance service is very poor and the financial requirement ‘will have a significant impact on our ability to expend across the board’.

The reforms to the ambulance service include significant cutbacks in the amount of overtime available, and stations may be closed down as a result of staff shortages. The use of private ambulance cover will be reduced significantly and, where possible, eliminated.

However the HSE have denied that there has been any cutbacks in the ambulance budget but they did not want to go over budget before year end and were ‘reducing inefficiencies in order to minimise impact on patient care’.

In the memo Mr Bonar stressed the service was facing a very difficult time. “I cannot over-emphasise the drastic financial situation that our service is facing. I wish to point out that 2009 will also be a very difficult financial year and the indications are that there will be a very limited rise in our budget allocation but that this will be more than offset by the inflationary increases expected to occur during the year,” he said.

Since these measures were put into practice, there have been instances of certain shifts not being filled in the Castlebar base and there was no ambulance available in Castlebar from 10pm until 11pm on Saturday, November 16, the night of the professional boxing fights in the Breaffy International Sports Hotel.

Independent Castlebar councillor, Michael Kilcoyne, told The Mayo News there was not enough permanent staff to cover the necessary shifts and because the HSE won’t pay for overtime, these shifts are being left vacant. He said he knew of a woman who missed her appointment for cancer treatment in UCHG because there was no ambulance to transfer her from Castlebar, and Cllr Kilcoyne believes someone will die as a result of the cut-backs.

“There have been times where there has been no active crew in Castlebar and the level of cover has been reduced substantially. Rosters are not being filled by crews and ambulances can’t be operated without a crew. There has been several cases of patients who are unable to be transferred from one hospital to another because there was no service.

“I know of a woman whose family had to arrange for the Order of Malta ambulance to bring her from Mayo General Hospital to her home in Louisburgh because there was no ambulance. These are unpaid volunteers who give up their time to do this when trained professionals are being left at home. I am saying as a result of these cut-backs people are going to die. If there is only one crew on duty and there are two emergencies, are they going to deal with one and let the other person die? That is not right,” he said

Fine Gael TD, John O’Mahony described as ‘absolutely scandalous’ an incident where an elderly man had to call a taxi to bring him home from hospital after having a serious procedure because no ambulance was available.

“Now this is absolutely scandalous and is simply not good enough. We’ve been told over and over again that the front line services will not be affected by the cutbacks but here’s another example of that not being the case. A situation appears to be emerging here where patients are being sent to hospital by ambulance by their GPs for treatment but there is no ambulance available to bring them home,” he said.

The HSE deny that the budget to the ambulance service in the west for 2008 has been cut but they claim they were legally obliged to remain within budget. In a response to questions from The Mayo News, the HSE said the full complement of ambulances in the region is available to deal with a major emergency in any part of a particular region.

“The ambulance service, like all other services within the HSE, has a legal obligation to remain within budget, which may mean generating savings between now and the end of 2008 to ensure that the service is not over-spent. The ambulance management team is committed to ensure that efforts to remain within the allocated budget focus mainly on reducing inefficiencies in order to minimise impact on patient care.

“The Ambulance Service is a national service, which means that the full complement of ambulances in a region is available to deal with a major emergency in any part of a particular region. If there was a major emergency in Mayo, ambulances from bordering counties can be called to assist ambulances based in the county to deal with the emergency,” the statement concluded.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice