Courts must treat victims of domestic abuse more evenly
Mayo women who are the victims of domestic violence can often find it difficult to access the statutory orders they are entitled to within the judicial system.
Courts must treat victims of domestic abuse more evenly
Aine Ryan
MAYO WOMEN who are the victims of domestic violence can often find it difficult to access the statutory orders they are entitled to within the judicial system and can be treated in ‘an inconsistent way’ by the various service providers, The Mayo News has learned.
Speaking to members of Mayo Women’s Support Services (MWSS) last week, it has also emerged that after gardaí advise victims ‘to get a barring order’, their expectations are raised, but then they are often refused in court and are thus left deflated, more isolated and totally frustrated with the system.
They also revealed that there is too much of an onus of proof on the women with an unbalanced emphasis on ‘physical violence’ while emotional abuse can be discounted in the courtroom.
“I think, from our experience, when going to court women feel they are further abused,” said Ms Bernadette Byrne, MWSS’s Assistant Manager.
However, Bernadette Byrne welcomed the establishment of the COSC office at the Department of Justice and the publication last month of its report on ‘Attitudes to Domestic Abuse in Ireland’. Established in 2007, COSC – which means ‘stop’ or ‘prevent’ – is the national office for the prevention of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence.
Her colleague, Ms Carmel Burke, a Women’s Support Worker added: “But still the protection and safety of women experiencing domestic violence in the legal system continues to be flawed.”
Moreover, Ms Carmel Burke also observed that, with COSC, and its report: “It’s the first time the services have been improved since we opened here in 1994. Awareness has been raised amongst the community at large and women are able to access services more quickly.”
Although Bernadette pointed to the telling statistic (from the survey) that 52 per cent of women believe that gardaí would not respond appropriately to a report and ‘would not treat the problem seriously enough’.
Survey results also show a very high percentage of people – say, neighbours who may suspect abuse is ongoing – are reluctant to become involved: 85 per cent feel it is not their business; 75 per cent feel their interference may make the situation worse; and 70 per cent feel it would not improve the safety of the victim.
The pivotal significance of COSC is that now there is ‘a formal recognition at ministerial level’ that domestic violence – physical, sexual and emotional – is wrong, both morally and legally.
“It is also significant that it advocates a co-ordinated response, that is the key,” said Bernadette Byrne.
Meanwhile, Carmel Burke emphasises that: “Inconsistencies in responses across the board to different cases of domestic violence can sometimes be simply down to the personalities of the gardaí, the social workers, the judges and the community workers.”
Both women said the establishment of a training programme for all service providers must be prioritised in order to understand the complexities of the issue.
Concluding, Carmel Burke said: “We should have a transparent and open judicial system that protects the people who come before it. All the agencies should be accountable and transparent.”