Court told man’s ear was severed with carpet knife
Two brothers who severed the ear of another man with a Stanley carpet knife were last week jailed at a Castlebar court.
Court told man’s ear was severed with carpet knife
TWO brothers who severed the ear of another man with a Stanley carpet knife while his two-year-old son held on to his trouser leg were last week jailed at Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court.
Simon and Michael McDonagh, with addresses at 57, Rowan Drive, Castlebar and Swindon, and 1, Marshaw Court, Bamburg Close, Reading, pleaded guilty to Section Two assault. An accomplice, Martin ‘Swinger’ Ward, of 2, Mons Terrace, Breaffy Road, Castlebar was also before the court, and identified as the driver on July 5, 2006.
Judge Raymond Groarke was told a feud between Traveller families, that originated 35 years ago, was the alleged cause of the assault, which was executed at the victim’s caravan on Bunree Road, Ballina.
Garda Tony Lavelle said the McDonaghs claimed the assault related to the injured party, (another) Martin Ward, having carried a knife into a gathering at Irvinestown, County Fermanagh and to a major public order fracas at a wedding in Bundoran, County Donegal, on June 30, 2006
Taking the stand, father of four, Martin Ward, who wears a patch over his right ear, showed Judge Groarke the wound. He said he was still undergoing the process of reconstruction of the ear. He also showed a scar across his face, which, after Simon McDonagh had cut off his ear, was incurred by Michael McDonagh as he left his caravan.
“My kid does be always talking about that day and asking me when am I getting my ear back. On the day he said: ‘I love you Daddy’ and blanked out for a short while in the caravan. When we went outside, there was a cup and he asked me did I want a drink. At the time, I thought I was going to die,” Martin Ward said.
“I’m a nervous person. I don’t like trouble,” he continued. “ I’m a soft victim. The argument they were having was with my brother-in-law and had nothing to do with me.”
Mr Martin Giblin, defence counsel for Martin ‘Swinger’ Ward and Simon McDonagh, said the former regretted the injury to the victim and had pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of impeding the course of justice. He also told Judge Groarke that Simon McDonagh had only intended to confront the victim on the day in question.
Barrister Eoin Garavan, representing Michael McDonagh, said his 28-year-old client, a father of four, had been addicted to crack cocaine and suffered from auditory hallucinations.
‘Utter savagery’ – Judge Groarke
RESPONDING, Judge Groarke asked: “Can you imagine any greater degree of utter savagery than holding a man while another cuts his ear off as a two-year-old child hangs on to his leg?”
“This is gross savagery. How can one human being do this to another?” he continued, adding that the victim was also slashed across the face.
Directly addressing the perpetrators, he asked: “Would you think about the legacy you have left for your own children. This two-year-old child is left scarred for life.”
Arguing that there was both planning and premeditation involved in the crime, he said he would impose the maximum sentence available to him.
“Talk about that in your caravans and at your weddings and funerals,” he said.
Imposing a two-year jail sentence, he noted that he had received positive testimonials about Martin ‘Swinger’ Ward, who has nine children one of whom has special needs.
Regarding Simon McDonagh, who was extradited from the UK and in custody since October 2009, he imposed a jail sentence of three years and nine months to be backdated. Michael McDonagh, who had medical difficulties at the time, was also given a sentence of three years and nine months.