COUNTY VIEW: So how many houses is enough?

Property demand is determined by a number of factors, any of which can skew the figures in either directionplaceholder image
Property demand is determined by a number of factors, any of which can skew the figures in either direction

John Healy looks at the problem of predicting future housing needs

If you feel confused at the blizzard of predictions about the national housing demand, there is no need to feel humble. In the welter of statistics, rebuttals, claims and counter claims and political posturing, the truth is that even the experts don’t have a clue. Every other week we hear conflicting stories of how many houses we need, of how many are in the pipeline, and of how, given time, the problem will be solved.

And the predictions vary wildly. The target outlined in the government’s official Housing for All plan was for an additional 33,000 homes per year. The ink was barely dry on that document when it was conceded that the figures were out of date. Then it was the turn of the new Taoiseach, who predicted that an average of 50,000 new homes would be built each year over the coming five years. Keen observers noted the get out ‘average’ epithet. (Simon Harris did not get to the top of the tree without good reason.)

To clear the air, the Government decided to take readings from three academic-type bodies, objective assessors who would crunch the numbers and come up with definitive answers.

The results, alas, were less than convincing. The ESRI eventually came up with a range of forecasts, depending on which future direction, economically and culturally, the country might take. That figure ranged from a low of 35,000 houses per annum, to a possible high of 53,000. Pick any number in between, it seemed to say, and you could be right.

The Housing Commission, set up to predict future trends, then set itself to work on the question. This time, the range of possible answers was even greater, from 31,400 a year at the lower end, to a high of 81,400, which left plenty of room for everyone to pick a number and claim to be right. The third estimate, based on the construction industry itself, went straight for the jackpot, confidently forecasting that Ireland’s housing needs would be 85,000 units each year.

If all of this sounds suspiciously like choosing your winning horse by sticking a pin into the list of runners, it might not be too far off the mark, albeit for credible reasons.

Housing demand is determined by a number of factors, any of which can skew the figures in either direction. It would take a crystal ball of remarkable acuity to determine how any of those factors will play out in the long term, much less to enable even a half accurate forecast to be arrived at.

All three teams of researchers point out that, apart from normal future needs, we have already a tailback of housing applicants who have been caught in the crossfire of a construction recession and a financial crisis. These are the adult children still living at home in the parental box room, and whose needs must be given priority before any future housing appetite can be satisfied.

But then comes the tricky part, the elephant in the room when it comes to future population growth. Future housing needs are tied to future population. As of now, the current projection is that our population will grow from 5 million to 6 million people within the coming two decades.

That growth of 1 million is based on one-third natural increase (the excess of births over deaths), and two thirds inward migration (or over half a million immigrants to live, work and make their permanent homes in Ireland). It is, by any measure, an expectation that is as tenuous as it is random, hostage to a whole range of global events that may, or may not, evolve.

And it may be a salutary reminder that the days of the ghost estates might yet come back to haunt us.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice