Counter claims at young mother’s inquest


A FATHER-OF-TWO whose wife died in Mayo General Hospital hours after giving birth has claimed she would be still alive today if she was given proper care at the hospital.Mrs Evelyn Flanagan (38) of Holyhill, Ballyheane, Castlebar, died on October 19 last year, hours after she had given birth to her second daughter, Niamh. The post mortem report on her death stated she died as a result of the poisonous amniotic fluid, which surrounded her baby in the womb, gaining access to her bloodstream.
Husband claims lack of care led to wife’s death
Evelyn Flanagan
A FATHER-OF-TWO whose wife died in Mayo General Hospital hours after giving birth has claimed she would be still alive today if she was given proper care at the hospital.
Mrs Evelyn Flanagan (38) of Holyhill, Ballyheane, Castlebar, died on October 19 last year, hours after she had given birth to her second daughter, Niamh. The post mortem report on her death stated she died as a result of the poisonous amniotic fluid, which surrounded her baby in the womb, gaining access to her bloodstream. The fluid gained access through a six-centimetre long tear in her uterus which occurred during childbirth.
However, Mrs Flanagan’s husband, Padraic, told the inquest into her death in Castlebar yesterday (Monday) that he was not happy with the level of care she received from the staff at the hospital after she had given birth. He said that, after giving birth, his wife lost 600ml of blood before staff became aware of the situation.
Mr Flanagan observed seeing blood drip from the underside of his wife’s bed and described how blood had soaked through the bedclothes and through the mattress of the bed. When the bed sheets were changed the fresh ones were soon soaked in blood again. He said the blood flowed from her uterus ‘as if it was being poured from a saucepan’.
He felt that the Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist, Dr Mohammed, did not do enough to find the source of the bleeding and wasted time before finally bringing her to the operating theatre. He said that from the time his wife gave birth, it took six-and-a-half hours for the medical team to locate and stop the bleeding. He said he felt if it was detected earlier she would have survived.
However, Dr Mohammed said he did all he could and claimed Mrs Flanagan would have died from the amniotic fluid embolism even if the bleeding had been stopped sooner.
The inquest continues today (Tuesday).
‘Unforgivable’ delay in getting blood recollected at inquest
Consultant denies that he could have done more to stem mother’s loss of blood
Anton McNulty
A FATHER who has been left to raise his two infant daughters on his own after his wife died hours after giving birth to their second child said his family’s life had been ‘torn apart and destroyed’.
Mr Padraic Flanagan, a Senior Executive Engineer with Mayo County Council, was speaking at the inquest into the death of his wife Evelyn (38) of Holyhill, Ballyheane, Castlebar, who died in Mayo General Hospital on October 19, 2007.
The post-mortem report on her death stated she died as a result of poisonous amniotic fluid, which surrounded her baby in the womb, gaining access to her bloodstream. The fluid gained access through a six-centimetre long tear in her uterus which occurred during childbirth.
The inquest heard that she lost 700ml of blood during birth and an additional 600ml before it was brought to the attention of the medical staff. Her husband, Padraic, told the inquest that after his wife had given birth their daughter Niamh, at 12.30pm on October 18, she was very, very weak and spoke in a low, monotonous, emotionless tone. He said she had little or no interest in wanting to hold her daughter and her monitor continued to flash and sound loudly and warn of low blood pressure.
During the next hour, he said her condition showed no sign of improving and he felt there was no air of urgency among the staff to address her condition. Mr Flanagan described having to hold his new-born daughter in one arm and hold the delivery room door open with his foot while he called the midwives to look at his wife’s condition.
At two o’clock, Mr Flanagan explained he saw blood drip from the underside of his wife’s bed and described how blood had soaked through the bedclothes and through the mattress of the bed.
“The entire bottom area of the bed around Evelyn’s legs and her abdomen was completely saturated in blood. Virtually the entire lower area of the bed was soaked in blood with the blood pooled in spots. I believe from what I saw that Evelyn had lost a number of pints of blood at this stage. The midwife immediately said this was ‘old’ blood and proceeded to change the bedclothes. No doctor was called and no examination took place,” he said.
Mr Flanagan said the new bedclothes were soon soaked in blood and said the blood flowed from her uterus as if it was being ‘poured from a saucepan’. He described a general air of panic and confusion in the room as Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist, Dr Murtada Mohammed, and his team tried to stop the bleeding. He said he saw one member of staff using a domestic Ever Ready flashlight to shine into Mrs Flanagan’s uterus to assist Dr Mohammed.
Mrs Flanagan was eventually brought to surgery and underwent a hysterectomy, which stopped the bleeding. However, during surgery she suffered two cardiac arrests and as her heart gradually weakened she died at 4am the following day.
Mr Flanagan was critical of a number of issues involved in the care of his wife, who was a private patient of Dr Mohammed. He said they chose to go private because they felt she would get the best care if something went wrong. He said Dr Mohammed was not present for the birth until near the end of the procedure and said that this surprised him. He also questioned how the midwives had not noticed the bleeding before he did if they had been monitoring the situation closely.
During the attempt to stem the bleeding, Mr Flanagan said his wife continued to bleed heavily. He described as ‘unforgivable’ the 70-minute period it took for blood to arrive to treat his wife. When the blood did arrive, he said there was no blood warmer in the delivery room and there was a delay in treatment until the blood warmer arrived some minutes later.
Mr Flanagan said timing was the key to saving his wife’s life and he felt that vital time was lost in attempting to save her. He asked a series of 43 questions, which he said now needed to be answered.
Dr Mohammed told the inquest that he was not concerned when Mrs Flanagan was bleeding and returned to his ante-natal clinic after he gave her some drugs to stop the bleeding. However, he said he soon retuned and, after another examination, he made the decision to transfer her to the theatre to find the source of the bleeding. He said they found that the uterus was ruptured with a 5cm tear and they decided to perform a sub-total hysterectomy.
Under cross-examination, he admitted not reading Mrs Flanagan’s file from her first pregnancy two years before, even though she lost at least two pints of blood after that birth. He explained that he never expected Mrs Flanagan to die from the bleeding and did not know about the amniotic fluid embolism until later.
He said this was difficult to diagnose and difficult to treat but denied that he could have done more to stem the loss of blood. He said that every woman who suffered bleeding could not be brought to theatre, otherwise ‘what happened in Drogheda’ would happen here.
The inquest continues during this week with a total of 21 witnesses expected to give evidence before it is completed.