Cottage ransacked after Debs party
Leaving Cert students from a Foxford secondary school were reprimanded by a judge at Castlebar Circuit Court last week.
Students found guilty after cottage is ransacked after Debs’ party
> 100 revellers cause €8,000 damage to house
> House was booked under false pretences
> Judge said Foxford men acted like ‘a pack of wolves’
LEAVING Cert students from a Foxford Ssecondary school were reprimanded by a judge at Castlebar Circuit Court last week after they failed to take responsibility for a cottage they rented under false pretences for a post-Debs party, which was then ransacked resulting, in thousands of euro worth of damage.
Both Jason Rice (19) of Gurteenamuck, Foxford and John Doherty (22) with an address at Pontoon Road, Foxford were found guilty of criminal damage to a holiday cottage and its contents in Ross, located between Pontoon and Castlebar. In the early hours of March 14, 2008 up to 100 people descended on the cottage for a post-Debs party and caused €8,000 worth of damage to the cottage.
The court heard how the 2008 Leaving Cert students of St Joseph’s Secondary School in Foxford duped Mr Mans Geerinck, the owner of the cottage into renting them the cottage after claiming the house was for relations coming on holiday. Neither of the two defendants were members of the class and Garda PJ Clarke who investigated the crime said there was huge reluctance by the students to give information.
The party took place after the Debs Ball in the Welcome Inn Hotel in Castlebar. The renting of the house was organised by the class as a whole with 40 pupils paying €15 each. Judge Raymond Groarke criticised the students of the class for failing to take responsibilities for their actions and said they had brought shame on themselves and on their school, and that they should all be sued.
“When the Garda arrived to the school, that was the time for the pupils to put their hand in their pocket to deal with the matter and put an end to it. Instead they brought shame up upon themselves and their school, which is utterly regrettable. I rebuke the Leaving Cert students for their irresponsible manner in which they dealt with the situation and instead of taking responsibility they ignored it and ran away,” he said.
The court heard how the cottage was completely ransacked with damage to every room in the house. There was water damage to the carpets, with dinner plates smashed and placed into the washing machine on a full-cycle, and kitchen units pulled off the wall. Salt was poured into the microwave and the toaster, doors were kicked in and light-bulbs smashed. Wardrobes and mirrors were smashed, holes were put in the ceiling and lipstick graffiti was written on the walls. Outside the house, the gutters and the down-pipe were ripped off the wall, the oil burner was pulled from its stand and the garden bench was broken.
In the investigation, Jason Rice’s fingerprint was one of only two fingerprints found in the house and in an interview with Garda PJ Clarke, he denied causing any damage to the house. In his statement to Gardaí, Mr Doherty admitted smashing some light bulbs because he said he found it funny.
Only one of the Leaving Cert class, Lena Morris from Foxford, told the court that she saw both Mr Rice or Mr Doherty causing damage to the house. She said the trouble had started when she got there and she said she saw Jason Rice messing with the kitchen cabinets and trying to pull them off the wall. She said she also saw John Doherty kicking in doors.
Lisa Sherrin admitted that she made the initial phone call to Mr Geerinck about the availability of the house and ‘pulling the wool over his eyes’. While she admitted the cottage was wrecked when she was leaving in the morning, but did not see anyone doing any damage to the house. Two other Leaving Cert students, Emer Burke and Liam Devaney said they did not see Mr Rice or Mr Doherty do any damage.
In his defence, Mr Rice said he was invited to the party and he went with his girlfriend. He said he was in the kitchen for over an hour but then went to a bedroom with his girlfriend and stayed there for the rest of the night. He denied damaging any part of the house and claimed he did not see anyone cause any damage.
When asked by Mr John Jordan, BL for the defence why Ms Morris said she saw him messing with the cupboard, he said he may have been opening the cupboard when he was looking for a glass. He denied that he was ‘brazening it out’ by denying everything put to him.
Ms Catherine Walsh, BL for Mr Rice said there was not one shred of evidence to point the finger at her client, while Mr Eoin Garavan, BL for Mr Doherty said the only evidence against his client was the admission in his statement to the Gardaí. Mr Jordan said there was evidence of the two defendants aiding and abetting in causing the damage to the house and they were liable for trial and prosecution.
After deliberating for an hour and a half, the jury of eight men and four women found the two men guilty of the charge of criminal damage. Judge Raymond Groarke accepted neither men had any criminal record or that this was their normal behaviour but they had behaved like ‘a pack of wolves’. The two accused men paid compensation - €5,000 in respect of Rice and €3,000 in respect of Doherty. Judge Groarke then applied the Probation Act and bound both defendants to the peace for three years. It is believed that at least one of defendants plan to appeal the jury’s decision to a higher court.