Corrib re-start

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

The talks concerning the Corrib gas project cannot be allowed to sink in the sand of time.

It is sad that the Corrib Dublin talks have broken down. They were not only promising but they signalled the first time that the Irish Government acknowledged that local people have rights. Some, including Ministers Éamon Ó Cuív and Eamon Ryan, admitted that mistakes have been made in dealing with the local people and the Corrib gas project. That admission in itself is something. Just because the talks have broken down does not mean that they have to be abandoned. Sniping and sarcasm, as is the wont of some groups, is best ignored in the circumstances. 

Minister Eamon Ó Cuív, as the senior Minister, is the man who must make every effort to get the talks back on track. The talks cannot be allowed to sink in the sands of time. Should they not re-start then they could be viewed as a cynical exercise by the State to tick a box stating that they ‘consulted’ locals. A European petitions case looms.   

Concerns affecting local people include health and safety, the environment, the role of gardaí, consents, the local authority, Shell and their representatives, to name but a few. Minister Eamon Ó Cuív acknowledged that some local people have genuine concerns about the role of gardaí. While law and order must be maintained so must respect for the local community.  Most of the gardaí carried out their duties responsibly but there are a few stories about gardaí that are simply shocking. There is a method for dealing with Garda complaints and that is being pursued. The question that is most often asked is why the Gardaí always appear to ‘take Shell’s side’ in any dispute? Senior gardaí only can answer that question. Naturally, when people break the law then they must face the full rigours of the law. It is unfortunate that the Corrib project has been blighted by people who think they have a divine right to do as they please, regardless of the local community or the rule of law. There is a huge difference between civil disobedience and law breaking. That is forgotten too often. 

What is also becoming an issue is the concern over the ongoing series of consents for the project. Many of those concerns have been highlighted in this column over the years. The Government must deal with these. One of these concerns is linked with proposed works at Glengad, the landfall site for the gas. A condition of the 2002 Consent to Construct an Upstream Pipeline (from the wellhead to the refinery) is that Shell provides an Environmental Management Plan (EMP), for the approval of the Minister (Eamon Ryan).  The EMP provides detailed construction methodology, traffic management, environmental impacts, monitoring, etc. Shell submitted the EMP in December 2008 to commence offshore works in 2009. Approval was granted last Thursday, yet nets were erected at Glengad on March 31 to stop sand martins nesting. Why erect nets in the nesting season? In February 2009, Shell applied for a new Consent to Construct with changes to the route and design of the pipeline, including pressure, a valve-station and changed outfall arrangement. With this consent application ‘live’ what is the status of the approved EMP? It seems that Shell can bring on a sub without taking a player off the field!  

This happened before. Port-a-loos, office cabins and fencing that were erected at Glengad last year were subsequently removed. Why? Was there no planning permission? Was consent in place? And which consent will be used to build the pipeline in the end? Will it have the wellhead consent from 2002 and the pipeline consent from 2009?

Minister Eamon Ó Cuív always states that you cannot revisit consents. He cites planning permission for a house as an example – once it is given, that’s it! Any objection to planning must be through the courts and a judicial review, he claims. The reality is that consents are different. They can be revisited and must. The law dictates that consents are granted based on legal requirements. Even Shell recognises this. That is why they applied for another Consent to Construct, because they had major revisions to the project. Major revisions require a new consent. That is the law.  It is up to the Minister to untangle the EMP versus the new consent application muddle. 

Meanwhile, gardaí are actively pursuing local people who removed the nets from Glengad recently. Was the erection of the nets on March 31 legal? If so, under which consent? Shell is silent. Gardaí have the power (some claim, the duty) under the Wildlife Act to check the authority for erecting such nets.  Have they done this? If not, why?  For everyone to benefit from this project there is an onus on people in power to ensure that it is done properly. Local people’s rights are inalienable.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice