Corrib forum ’balanced’ and ’inclusive’

placeholder image

GOVERNMENT’S new initiative on the controversial Corrib gas project, and general development of north-west Mayo, has been deemed ‘timely, balanced, inclusive, comprehensive and meaningful’.

Corrib forum ‘balanced’ and ‘inclusive’

Áine Ryan

GOVERNMENT’S new initiative on the controversial Corrib gas project, and general development of north-west Mayo, has been deemed ‘timely, balanced, inclusive, comprehensive and meaningful’ by the Council for the West.

Council chairman, Mr Seán Hannick, said the establishment of a Community Forum for Development in north-west Mayo, announced jointly on Thursday last by Ministers Eamon Ryan and Éamon Ó Cuív, was ‘a holistic approach that deserved to be given a fair chance by all interests in the region’.

Chaired by Joe Brosnan, a retired senior civil servant, the community forum will focus broadly on economic development in this remote region. It will also address specific contentious issues about the Corrib project including compliance with permits and licences, safety, technology and environmental management.  

In a statement, Mr Hannick observed that for ‘too long the debate has been around a single issue, the Corrib gas find, and how it might be utilised’.

“In a sense, that has led to differing views from differing groups, while the Government, which should have been playing a much more helpful and understanding role from the outset, stood back when leadership and vision were needed to alleviate a difficult situation,” he said.

Originally established by the western bishops to campaign for Objective One Status, the Council for the West is an independent group that lobbies for economic development in the region.

In the eight-year Corrib debacle, the new initiative is the first Government-backed intervention since the appointment of mediator, Peter Cassells, after the release of the Rossport Five in 2005.

While there has been broad welcome for the forum, the Campaign for Protection of Resources (CPR) has warned that it is ‘doomed to failure unless it has a total understanding of the opposition to the project as currently constituted’.

“The local community, through Pobal Chill Chomáin and the area’s priests, has put forward a compromise location for this gas refinery which is backed by Bishop of Killala Dr John Fleming and both Labour and Fine Gael politicians. This project can benefit both the State and the local community if done properly,” said Mr Padhraig Campbell of CPR.

Meanwhile, Mr Fergus McAllister, Chairman of the Mayo branch of the Green Party, welcomed Minister Ryan’s comments about earmarking Mayo as a renewable energy hub, by ‘combining renewable energy sources of wind and wave’ with a new gas plant.

The Pro-Gas Mayo group observed that independent mediator, Mr Peter Cassells, ‘was engaged in a similar process’ and that many of his recommendations had benefited Mayo already.

“It behoves everybody of goodwill to participate and work with this new body, rather than rubbish it as a ‘talking shop’ and dismissing it out of hand,” said Secretary, Mr Brendan Cafferty.

The establishment of the community forum follows discussion held by the two ministers with a broad range of vested interests in Ballina during September last. 

Welcoming the forum, a spokesman for Shell said the company looks forward to ‘participating wholeheartedly’ in its work.

“We reiterate our long-standing commitment to engage in constructive dialogue with any individuals or groups who have genuine concerns about the Corrib project and will work with the forum’s Chairman, Mr Joe Brosnan, to achieve this goal,” said the spokesman.“

“We hope that the new forum will also leverage development opportunities that will flow for the Corrib project – so as to enhance the long-term social and economic development of Erris and Co Mayo,” he continued.

Deputy Beverley Flynn and Cllr Micheál McNamara have also welcomed the initiative, with each expressing the hope that it will lead to a resolution to the conflict.

WHAT THE MAIN PLAYERS SAID

Minister Eamon Ryan

“The Corrib gas project has been a protracted and sometimes painful process for many of the people involved. The Government has a duty to protect the rights of all its citizens. This includes local communities and the developer who is working under statutory consents granted. The Government also has a duty to act in the best interests of the Irish people. For energy security of supply and economic development, I believe this project is in the national interest.”

Minister Éamon Ó Cuív

“Northwest Mayo and Erris in particular have suffered huge emigration and population loss in the past.  Its people often had to go to the industrial cities of Britain and America to find employment. What we aim to do with the forum is to seek to create common ground for the positive development of the area and to mediate differences in a constructive way.

“With the establishment of this forum, there is a historic opportunity to address the challenges of the past and to ensure that all of the natural resources of the Erris region are put to work for the people there.”

Forum Chairman, Joe Brosnan

“The purpose of the forum is to provide an opportunity for dialogue between people with widely differing views. Chairing the discussions in the forum will be a big challenge. I will do my very best to be an honest broker for frank, open and constructive dialogue over the months ahead.

“I bring no baggage to this subject, I’ve had no previous involvement in it whatsoever.”

Community fears must take precedence

POBAL CHILL CHOMÁIN REACTION

ADDRESSING the original fears of the community receiving the controversial Corrib gas project and not other aspects of economic development in Erris must be the priority of the newly-established forum, according to Pobal Chill Chomáin.

In a written response, sent yesterday (Monday) to Ministers Eamon Ryan, Éamon Ó Cuív and forum Chairman, Mr Joe Brosnan, the group welcomes, ‘in principle’, the establishment of the forum which aims ‘to facilitate dialogue on the local issues relating to the Corrib gas project’.

“None of us wants to see a return to the events of this summer where the lives of members of our community were put in danger as a result of this controversial project,” writes Chairman, Mr Vincent McGrath.

“Our community has always favoured dialogue as the most effective means of solving the controversial issues in relation to this project. However, we believe that dialogue must be open, genuine and sincere in order to maximise the potential for success.”

However, he stresses that if the forum is to succeed, it must prioritise the core issues of ‘health and safety of our community, protection of our unspoiled environment, community consent and establishment of respect and trust between all key stakeholders’.

He continues: “Any attempt to prioritise economic development or to explore improved economic benefits for the Erris area with other secondary parties, prior to addressing the original fears and concerns of the receiving community, will cause insult and offence and will be totally counter productive to the process.”

Mr McGrath observes that a condition of Pobal Chill Chomáin’s involvement is that Mr Brosnan confirms that these core issues are prioritised, as well as Corrib’s design concept, site location and adherence to best international practice.

He also notes that both the State and the developer must come to the forum ‘open to the idea of compromise’, and that the people of the parish of Kilcommon should be recognised as the receiving community and key stakeholders, ‘therefore warranting precedence in the decision-making process’.

“If the core issues of trust and respect for the local receiving community are addressed we can unite and move forward together in bringing this project to a successful conclusion,” the letter concludes.

Responding to the announcement of a community forum, Shell to Sea spokeswoman, Maura Harrington, told The Mayo News yesterday that ‘consultation’ was ongoing.

“Shell to Sea is still consulting and reflecting with all our groups nationwide and abroad. They are being afforded that courtesy, unlike the lack of consultation by the two Ministers who announced last week’s initiative without informing any of us,” said Ms Harrington.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice