Comment on website over GAA incident costs Bohola man €50,000

placeholder image

Judge says comments were ‘ill-informed’ and cast a ‘terrible slur’ on father and son

A BOHOLA man has been ordered to pay a father and son €25,000 each for defaming them after writing a comment on an Irish news website.

A sitting of the Castlebar Circuit Civil Court ruled that Andrew Malee of Carracastle, Bohola, defamed both Jonathan Clarke and his father James, both of Woodstock, Ballindine, after writing a comment about the men in the comments section of news website thejournal.ie on October 17, 2015.

The article in question related to a court case where a Moy Davitts player was jailed on October 16, 2015 for assault causing harm to Jonathan Clarke. The assault occurred during a GAA match between Davitts and Moy Davitts which resulted in Mr Clarke losing 95 percent of his sight in his left eye.

Mr Malee and the player who was jailed are clubmates with the Moy Davitts GAA Club, located in Foxford, and the comment was written at 10.48pm while Mr Malee was in a public house. He claimed the comment was written in ‘the spur of the moment’ in response to comments on thejournal.ie website. Mr Malee removed the comment the following day.

In making the order, Judge Francis Comerford said the comments were ‘ill-informed’ and cast a ‘terrible slur’ against those they were made against. While he said there was a lot of loose talk said in pubs, it was more serious to put it in writing, where tens of thousands of people could see it.

Mr Malee was sued for defamation by the two Clarkes who stated that the words of the comment in their nature and meaning were understood to mean that they were liars and were motivated by spite and malevolence.

It was also claimed they would be shunned by ‘right thinking people and in particular, by people who were interested in the wellbeing and integrity of the GAA’.

In his judgement, Judge Comerford said it was clear the comment caused substantial damage to the reputation of the plaintiffs. He added that an offer of €15,000 by the defendant was not anywhere near approaching the number to cover for the level of damage caused.

See next week’s Mayo News for more details from the case.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice