Chorus debacle costs council
THE debacle that was the attempted installation of an MMDS system in Castlebar by Chorus in 2000 was fully exposed at last week’s meeting of Castlebar Town Council.
Chorus debacle ends up costing Castlebar Council
Michael Duffy
THE debacle that was the attempted installation of an MMDS system (Multichannel Multipoint Distribution Service) in Castlebar by Chorus in 2000 was fully exposed at last week’s meeting of Castlebar Town Council, with the Council executive admitting that overall the deal had cost the Council money, despite the job never having being completed.
Town Clerk, Marie Crowley, told the meeting that legal fees for a senior and junior counsel and a solicitor who represented the Council in the High Court had cost the Council €62,000 in total.
Chorus had taken the Council to the High Court after the Council had refused to return the company’s bond. The Council had intended to use the bond to complete works which the company had left unfinished at different locations around Castlebar.
A previous meeting of the Council had heard a frank admission from the executive that there was never a written agreement with Chorus in relation to the work, that the piping and wiring that was laid will never be used and that the Council do not have maps of where the work was carried out.
Again, most councillors at last week’s meeting used the opportunity to drive home their disillusionment with the whole saga, calling it ‘the epitome of bad management’ and ‘public administration at its worst’.
Cllr Michael Kilcoyne said it was now clear from the figures that Chorus’s failings ended up actually costing the Council money.
“Chorus gave this Council €152,369 of a bond but we ended up giving them back €100,000 in a settlement on the steps of the High Court and now we learn we paid over €62,000 in legal fees.”
Cllr Noel Campbell said the whole saga made Castlebar Town Council look ‘naïve, stupid and corrupt’, but Director of Services, Mr Seamus Granahan, said he refuted the use of the word ‘corrupt’.
“I take exception to the use of the word corrupt. We have learned lessons from the situation but in the end we took advice and it was damage limitation. The decision to seek legal advice is an executive one.”
However, Mr Granahan agreed with a suggestion from Cllr Aidan Crowley that elected members be informed, confidentially, if the Council are be involved in litigation of a controversial nature in the future.