Charting progress

placeholder image

IT is a truism that Catholicism has been a major influence in shaping the social landscape of Ireland.

“Mary Delany, whose gregarious letters vividly illuminate the opulent world of ascendancy Ireland, claimed she ‘never saw a greater appearance of misery’ than in the village of Killala. It made her ‘heart ache’, though not for long”

Second Reading

Some diocesan histories exist. For the most part they were written in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, a kind of golden age for priest historians. The study of local history was a leisure-time pursuit for priests before they discovered golf. These volumes are now difficult to obtain, their rarity reflected in the high prices they command in antiquarian book shops.

Older diocesan histories require up-dating in the light of modern research. Often they are written in a hagiographical tone which also limits their value. Bishops and priests are generally presented as paragons of virtue. Awkward facts are either obscured or excluded. A flavour of the tone is conveyed in a Western People report of the 1930s which described the then Bishop of Killala, Dr Naughton, as ‘the most beloved bishop who has ever had charge of this ancient diocese’. He merited this syrupy adulation merely because he had authorised the celebration of an extra Mass in the cathedral.

One is reminded of Ambrose Bierce’s definition of a saint – ‘a dead sinner revised and edited’!

In recent years three volume histories on the dioceses of Killaloe and Achonry have been published. The late Ignatius Murphy and Liam Swords, respectively, deserve credit for their work. These volumes set the standard by which future diocesan histories will be judged. They evoke the religious experience not just of priests and bishops, but the entire Catholic community. They are well-researched, comprehensive in detail and judicious in tone.

For the past few years, Fr Brendan Hoban has been working on a history of the diocese of Killala. The first fruits of his labour, ‘A Melancholy Truth. The Travels and Travails of Fr Charles Bourke, 1765 - 1820’, has just been published. In this book he painstakingly pieces together the story of a mercurial priest who had an unusual career.

Apart from giving substance to one who had until now been a shadowy figure, the book is notable for its insight into life in the diocese of Killala as it emerged from the penal days.

Killala, a small diocese of 22 parishes, from Ballycroy in Mayo to Skreen in Sligo, was, in the 18th century, remote and impoverished. In winter time some parts of it were inaccessible. Mary Delany, whose gregarious letters vividly illuminate the opulent world of ascendancy Ireland, claimed she ‘never saw a greater appearance of misery’ than in the village of Killala. It made her ‘heart ache’, though not for long.

John Brett, who served as Bishop of Killala in the 1730s, did not find it a comfortable billet. He felt he had been consigned to a ‘western Siberia’. Dominic Bellew, the diocese’s longest-serving bishop in the 18th century, spent most of his episcopate seeking a transfer to more prosperous pastures. Before his appointment to Killala, he had been parish priest of Dundalk. During his lengthy incarceration in the marshes of Mayo, he ruefully reflected it was worth ‘five Killalas’. Shades of Dean Swift who, on reluctantly accepting the post of Dean of St Patrick’s Cathedral, mused his fate could have been worse – it could have been Killala.

It was into this world that Charles Bourke was born in 1765 in Ballycastle. He belonged to a comfortable family who could afford to educate him. By the mid-1780s he had started his studies for the priesthood at the Irish College in Salamanca in Spain.

Here his penchant for controversy asserted itself. He was one of a group of students who protested to the King of Spain and the Irish bishops about the draconian regime in the seminary.

Ordained in 1792, he opted, not to return to his native diocese, but to join a Spanish Mission to Louisiana where he became the first parish priest of Baton Rouge. He made a significant contribution to the organisation of the parish. However, he got into trouble with his bishop after he was involved in an altercation following an alcohol-fuelled Christmas dinner in 1796.

As a result, he thought it better to return to Ireland where he worked in the diocese of Killala for ten years. In 1811, desirous of more adventurous travel, and without the permission of his bishop, he joined Sir Thomas Selkirk’s expedition as chaplain to a proposed colony of Irish Catholics and Scottish Presbyterians in what is now Manitoba, Minnesota and North Dakota. Quarrelsome and addicted to alcohol, he was found unsuitable for the post and sent home before the expedition reached its destination.

On his return to the diocese of Killala, he and others opposed the appointment of Tuam priest, Peter Waldron, as bishop. Later he excoriated the administration of Waldron in a pamphlet. Hoban concludes that he may have finished his career as a Church of Ireland clergyman.

Historians are detectives of the past. In this book, Brendan Hoban proves himself an able sleuth. No doubt we can look forward to further volumes on quirky clerics from his prolific pen.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice