Changing times at school

placeholder image

Second Reading In 1982, as Minister for Education in Garret Fitzgerald’s first Government, the late John Boland made an important decision - to abolish corporal punishment in schools.

Fr Kevin Hegarty

The poet, Patrick Kavanagh, detested school. Sent there at the age of four he did not want to go as he had heard disturbing tales about the teachers, Miss Cassidy and Miss Moore.

He had caught a glimpse of Miss Cassidy on her way to school; “A big woman with a heavy, coarse face”, carrying a bundle of yellow canes. She looked ‘like a girl who could use them for all they were worth’.

The assistant mistress, Miss Moore, was ‘thin and wiry’. He heard ‘enough about her to make me want to go to America’. In school, ‘seven or eight hard slaps on each hand was a common thing and on top of that maybe a bonus of a box on the ear’.

Kavanagh’s earthy reminiscences reflect a time when corporal punishment was an integral part of the school curriculum. Seamus Heaney remembers occasions in St. Columb’s College in Derry when ‘the leather strap / went epileptic in the Big Study’.

In National School, I had a teacher whose first activity each morning was to fumble under her desk in the box of canes to choose the weapon she considered most suitable for the day. One of them was a discarded leg of a chair. I got many a blow of it and I was very quiet!

Brendan Kennelly, in his poem ‘The Stick’, evokes the callous care with which a teacher prepared a cane for use in the classroom.

“The man walked out of the classroom

And strode to the end of the yard

Where the ash tree was in bloom.

It was a calm day, the leaves barely stirred

As he searched the tree for the right strip.

He tried many pieces, threw them aside.

At last, he found the right size and shape

And with his knife sculpted

A thin hard stick, his work of art.

Back in the room, he looked at the boys’ faces.

They’d be farmers, labourers, even singers, fiddlers and dancers.

He placed the stick on the mantelpiece above the fire.

His days were listening to boys’ voices

Who’d know the stick if they didn’t know the answer”.

In 1982, as Minister for Education in Garret Fitzgerald’s first Government, the late John Boland made an important decision - to abolish corporal punishment in schools. Children cannot learn creatively in an atmosphere darkened by violence.

Violence can also breed violence. Peter Tyrell, in ‘Founded on Fear’, an agonising memoir of his time in Letterfrack Industrial School, states “the child who is beaten by someone bigger and stronger than himself, will very often grow up bitter and full of hatred of society. He will want to get his own back. He may one day hit back”.

Boland’s decision was welcomed, not least by long-suffering students. Most parents and teachers accepted that corporal punishment was a barbarous form of class control though some wondered how discipline now might be maintained in schools. Discipline is essential in the classroom but a civilised society has to find appropriate, non-violent ways of imposing it.

Today we have a more comprehensive understanding of the rights of children. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child is a universal index of this recognition.

How we care for children shapes the future of our society. In his tender reflection, ‘Letter to Daniel’, the foreign correspondent, Fergus Keane, reflects lyrically on how the birth of his son influenced him.

“Your coming has turned me upside down and inside out... Now looking at your sleeping face, inches away from me, listening to your occasional sigh and gurgle, I wonder how I could ever have thought glory and prizes and praise were sweeter than life. And it is also true that I am pained, perhaps haunted is a better word, by the memory, suddenly so vivid now, of each suffering child I  have come across in my journeys. To tell the truth, it is nearly too much to bear at this moment, to think of children being hurt and abused and killed”.

Much remains to be done to protect and enhance the rights of children. This became clear at the conference of the European network of Ombudsmen for Children, held in Dublin last week. Yanghee Lee, the Chairperson of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, found it alarming, for example, that some states are re-introducing corporal punishment for children.

She made the point that human rights institutions, like the office of Children’s Ombudsman, are valuable in monitoring a state’s implementation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The Irish Ombudsman, Emily Logan, told the conference that she deals with 750 cases a year. Furthermore, we know that in 2005, 2,300 children were taken into care because of neglect, the inability of their parents to cope, or because of physical, sexual or emotional abuse.

A recent television documentary reported on cases of abuse which had not been investigated despite the social services being alerted.

Emily Logan deserves support for her proposal that an amendment on children’s rights be included in the Constitution. Hopefully the proposal will not become a political football.

How we treat the vulnerable is an index of the civility of a society.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice