CCTV debate
De Facto With winter looming and the long dark nights already inching closer, the debates are being lined up.
De Facto
Liamy MacNally
With winter looming and the long dark nights already inching closer, the debates are being lined up. What will the topics be to see us over the threshold and blow the cold winter away? The energy coils that wind their grip around the winter months need to be unravelled. One of the issues that will thaw many a mind over the next few months is the presence of CCTV cameras.
These closed circuit television cameras go hand in hand with childcare supports, at least in the amount of funding available from the Department of Justice. One wonders what kind of bureaucratic bent has grafted both issues onto the funding branches dripping with grants.
There is a move in Westport to install these cameras at selected locations in the town centre. The locations have not been made public, yet. Some will argue that they have not even been chosen, while others know how the system works. The details are agreed, the plan is drawn up, the public is ‘consulted’ and the ‘final’ plan is presented as the ‘agreed’ plan. And the coup de grace will always be the claim that if we do not apply for the funding now, it will be lost and we will all lose out on what is deemed to be a very worthwhile project. Safer streets and all that! There is nothing like the little bit of emotional seasoning thrown into any discussion.
GARDAÍ AND COMMUNITY CCTV
In Ireland the Gardaí operate less than a dozen CCTV systems with more than another dozen planned. Almost as many community-operated schemes are in the pipeline. Placed alongside these schemes are the many ‘private’ CCTV cameras operating in public areas under the guise of ‘business security.’ There are few, if any, streets one can walk in Westport from one end to the other without having your ‘mug shot’ recorded, and you totally unaware of it. Castlebar Road, Castlebar Street, North Mall, South Mall, Bridge Street (umpteen times), Shop Street, James Street and Mill Street all boast CCTV cameras. Other streets probably do also. People are being recorded as they go about their daily lives, many of them oblivious to their presence on the reel of videotape. What rights does any person have when it comes to CCTV, if any? Who can ‘use’ the recorded tapes and for what purposes? Must permission be sought from the people ‘appearing’ on the tapes? Is there a breach of privacy by recording people without their knowledge, much less their consent?
CCTV REGULATION
CCTV regulation in this country is minimal. All operatives of CCTV must display a sign stating that a camera is in operation. If there is no such sign then the operator is in breach of the Data Protection Acts. Like the ‘No Smoking’ signs, the contact name and number must also be displayed on the signs. Any interested party can now take a ‘CCTV walk’ around Westport and see how many times the law is being flouted by private businesses.
With community CCTV schemes the big question centres around who will view or ‘manage’ the tapes? People are entitled to roam freely in a so-called democracy. The last thing anyone needs is a busybody do-gooder having access to such recordings. Many people would also prefer if Gardaí did not have access to such footage, especially when there is nothing to investigate. The great argument , however, centres on the presence of CCTV cameras to stem the spread of public order offences.
Many towns are experiencing an unwelcome rise in petty crime and public disorder. There is a belief that CCTV cameras will act as the magic wand in these cases. What do people expect? Do they think that the presence of cameras will stop such unwelcome actions? John Collins, writing in The Irish Times recently, cited the British experience where cameras are being used less and less as a crime reduction tool and more as intelligence gathering. He cites a 2005 study of 14 CCTV cameras by the University of Leicester, which found that ‘cameras are not having the expected impact on crime…’ The only positive result was a reduction of vehicle crime in car parks. The presence of cameras did not make people feel any safer in a community.
The CCTV issue was raised at a recent Westport Town Council meeting. It is now a hot topic on the council agenda. It is to be explored further. In this country, it is usually town and city councils along with chambers of commerce who lead the cause for installing CCTV. All applications for funding to the Government must have the support of the Gardaí. Once the application is successful then the Gardaí or a private ‘security’ firm is employed to monitor the CCTV.
ROLE OF THE GARDAÍ
The world of Big Brother is best exemplified in Britain where there are over four million CCTV cameras recording the daily movements of its subjects. Here there have been many calls for proper regulation before the installation of CCTV cameras becomes the latest fad and phenomenon for every town and village in the country. The debate also begs the question about the role of Gardaí in the roll out of CCTV cameras. Does it mean that they will in future be more confined to barracks than they already are? The majority of people want to see more gardaí on the streets.
That is not only the best deterrent for any would-be criminal or offender but it also provides the most reassurance to local communities, more than any amount of CCTV cameras.While there are many gardaí who would prefer to be ‘on the beat’ rather than pen pushing in the barracks, there seems to be a management style that demands that gardaí spend more time at base rather than on the streets. There must be a value placed on the presence of the gardaí on the streets rather than always putting a price on the number of gardaí in a division.
BIGGER BIG BROTHER
For those who complete the ‘CCTV walk’ around Westport, or any town for that matter, they can also mull on other ‘security’ and ‘privacy’ issues. This current crop of elected TDs has plans, now part of Government policy, to register all mobile phones. At present, details of all mobile phone calls are retained for three years. Travel information, especially for America trips, now contains masses of personal data. Internet records are kept for 18 months and all sites you visit can be tracked.
The Government can access bank details and seek information about money transfers. Various cards, from loyalty cards to credit cards and library cards, all retain details of what you spend, where and what you read. Mayo County Council’s regulation that every household must prove that they dispose of their refuse properly can be easily matched up by the powers now adopted by Big Brother. What a pity such council acumen could not have been utilised to provide a proper refuse collection in the first place. On top of this is all the personal detail retained by various bodies and professionals about everyone. Install more cameras? Why not employ more Gardaí?