Mayo councillor fails in plea for increased community support from windfarms


Castlebar councillor Harry Barrett failed to get support to defer agreement on Eirgrid project in order to get better community benefit fund deal
A MAYO councillor failed to get support to defer an agreement on North Connacht 110kV project in order to get community benefit funds from windfarms increased and index linked with the increased price of electricity.
Castlebar-based Independent councillor Harry Barrett made the call at the May monthly meeting of Mayo County Council during a discussion on the EirGrid North Connacht 110kV project.
The project which was granted planning permission by An Coimisiún Pleanála in 2023 includes the installation of an underground cable between the Moy substation near Ballina and the Tonroe substation close to Ballaghaderreen.
Councillors agreed that Mayo County Council enter into an agreement with Roscommon County Council that the powers, functions and duties necessary for the development of the scheme situated in Roscommon shall be performed by Mayo County Council.
While expressing his support for the project and wind energy, Cllr Barrett felt that communities were not benefiting from the increased generation of electricity from wind farms.
“We're in a situation at the moment where we have record numbers, we cannot pay their electricity bills and people are falling into arrears.
“We have an appalling community benefit scheme of €2 per megawatt, not index linked. It's been like that now for over 15 years. We're losing money as inflation eats into it. So this is a scandal, as far as I'm concerned an absolute scandal,” he told the meeting.
Proposal
The Independent councillor added that the majority of power produced by windfarms will go towards powering data centres who he claimed will not be paying the same rate for electricity as the normal household.


Cllr Harry Barrett
“What I'm trying to say here today is that we have leverage on this decision here today. I'm saying that we stall this decision until wind operators sit down and negotiate a proper fair community benefit scheme for the people of County Mayo. This is crucial.
“I am now fed up with the tokenism that we've been offered here. We don't want the crumps from the table anymore, and we don't want an outdated payment system. All we need is a substantial increase in the community contribution index linked built into all agreements
“I want a long term funding coming out of these wind operations that reflects the value being generated in County Mayo from its natural resources,” he said.
The Community Benefit Funds are funded by mandatory financial contributions made by renewable energy projects supported by the Renewable Electricity Support Scheme.
While there was sympathy for what Cllr Barrett was proposing he received no support to defer the agreement which was passed by the council.
Inward Investment
Erris-based councillor Gerry Coyle who described the money generated for communities from windfarms as 'an absolute disgrace' said that deferring the North Connacht project further is not the answer.
“I fully appreciate what you say Harry but I wouldn't stop infrastructure being built. I wouldn't cut off my nose to spite my face but I want to see better and want it index linked. It didn't happen, but we have to do it in the future, but we don't want to stop infrastructure that's going to benefit us all,” he said.
The meeting heard contributions from other councillors who commented that energy efficiency has never been more important than ever and that nothing should hold up the project.
Fianna Fáil councillor Damien Ryan said it was critical that Mayo had the power and supply to sustain inward investment into the county.
“I get where Cllr Barrett is coming from and I am as frustrated as everyone else in relation to the rates that have been set.
“But don't stall the network and don't jeopardise the grid. Look at what can be attained for the communities and for countries like this that have the interconnectors going through them. I think that it's important that the reward should also be part and parcel of what we're doing as regards the heavy lifting,” he commented.
Sinn Féin councillor Gerry Murray said that the deregulation of the network has resulted in Ireland having one of highest prices for electricity in Europe despite wind farms being heavily subsidised.
“It's high time that we took back control of our public utilities, and until that is done we won't be in control of the situation. I appreciate what Cllr Barrett is saying, but that's the only cure. In the meantime, this piece of infrastructure is essential, and it has to go through.
“There's a huge consensus around the country that we need to take back power by taking back all of our utilities and services into state ownership. And that's what gives democracy its intrinsic value,” he said.
Following the discussion, Cllr Barrett reiterated that he is not against the project but felt that something has to be done to address the cost of electricity and support communities affected by wind farms.
“All I am saying is that as councillors we use this opportunity as leverage to say, just hold on, can we have a quick conversation about community values? Can we do the decent things here and give us what other nations across Europe do to make communities better.
“We agreed at our last meeting to increase the community benefit fund and this is a moment in time. We can't go on handing away our natural resources on the cheap,” he said.
Enhancing grid
Mayo County Council Director of Services, David Mellett said that while the project will support renewable energy, it is not connected to any local renewable energy project and is about enhancing the grid.
Cllr Barrett was also informed that the council has written to the Commission for Regulation of Utilities in relation to increasing the community benefit fund and they are awaiting a response.
