Broadband scheme is ’inadequate’ and flawed

THE National Broadband Scheme, which was unveiled with great fanfare last week, will not offer the service to all parts of rural Mayo.

Broadband scheme is ‘inadequate’ and ‘flawed’

New National Broadband Scheme criticised for not covering all Mayo communities

Anton McNulty

THE National Broadband Scheme (NBS), which is supposed to provide 100 per cent broadband coverage to all of Ireland, has been heavily criticised in Mayo, as many rural areas of the county currently without a reliable broadband connection have been omitted from the scheme. Furthermore, it has been claimed that the technology to be used in the scheme is inadequate and will not be able to guarantee high-speed connections.

Last week, the Minister for Communications Éamon Ryan announced that the Government had entered into a scheme with communications company ‘3’, with a view to providing 100 per cent broadband coverage in Ireland by September 2010. The majority of communities in Mayo are included in the NBS but a number of communities have been omitted despite not being able to avail of high-speed broadband at present.

Rural communities affected by this omission include parts of Louisburgh, Foxford, Kiltimagh and Kilmovee, while in Achill part of the island which already has a broadband connection is included in the NBS, with the area without broadband – known as ‘Lower Achill’– omitted from the scheme.

The omission has angered many residents in Achill who believed they would finally have a broadband connection available inside 21 months. Mr Terence Dever, CEO of Comhlacht Forbartha Áitiúil Acla (CFÁA), told The Mayo News it was imperative that Minister Ryan solved the anomaly of broadband availability in Achill.

He explained that CFÁA had been in correspondence with Eircom for the past number of years requesting that all of Achill be broadband-enabled – but without success. He said the area excluded is the hub of Achill’s tourism industry and without broadband they are losing out on business.

“We were hoping that, with the introduction of the National Broadband Scheme, all of Achill would be connected but it seems that we have been left out again. Broadband is so important to development on the island in terms of tourism and business and this is an another kick in the teeth. We are demanding that Minister Ryan solve the broadband problem in Achill because the situation that exists at present is a joke,” he said.

A spokesperson for the Department of Communications told The Mayo News that the part of Achill Island not covered by the scheme already has broadband availability from ‘3’. She added that because EU State Aid and competition rules prevent the State from intervening in areas where there are existing service providers, the NBS is prohibited from providing a service in served areas.

In response Mr Dever said he was aware of the ‘3’ service but feels that the plug-in modem service provides neither an adequate nor affordable service to the tourism industry on the island.

The €223 million investment will see ‘3’ extend its network to provide mobile wireless broadband services into the NBS areas, with a minimum download speed of 1.2 mb per second.

However, this service has been heavily criticised, with Mr Joe Kelly of IRD Kiltimagh describing the speed as ‘midband’. He feels the NBS is not the solution to providing broadband to rural Ireland.

Mr Eamonn Wallace of Ireland Offline – the group which campaigns for broadband internet access in Ireland – told The Mayo News that the technology used will not support the advertised headline speeds.

“The technology cannot guarantee the high speeds because the more people that use the service the more the speed will drop. If it guaranteed 1.2 mbps it would be great, but it can’t. If you want to speak to your brother or sister in Australia on Skype and the connection speed drops, it won’t connect the call anymore. Technically, this scheme has a lot of flaws and is more likely to turn people off the idea of broadband,” he said.

Mr Wallace feels that the Minister was badly briefed on this service and while, theoretically, there will be 100 per cent broadband coverage around Ireland, it will not be guaranteed high speed. He said Ireland needed high-speed broadband to compete with other countries but feels if we accept the ‘just enough’ mentality the country will get just enough when it needs much more.

Mayo Fine Gael TD, Michael Ring welcomed the principle of Minister Ryan’s announcement but he too was concerned about the proposal to use mobile broadband on a mobile network.

“ComReg and many other commentators continue to question the reliability and capacity of mobile broadband technologies, particularly in a business context. If this is the basis for the Minister’s solution it will simply not be good enough for rural areas and that will mean missed commercial opportunities as well as ongoing frustration for residents,” he said.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice