Bohola man loses landmark Lotto case

The Supreme Court has ruled that a Mayoman who laid claim to one-fifth of a Lotto jackpot win by a Ballyvary-based syndicate in 2001 has no entitlement to any money. Now, Martin Horan of Carragown, Bohola, Castlebar, faces the prospect of an enormous legal bill.

Bohola man loses landmark Lotto case

Supreme Court rules in favour of four syndicate members, leaving huge legal bill to fifth

Neill O’Neill

THE Supreme Court has ruled that a Mayoman who laid claim to one-fifth of a Lotto jackpot win by a Ballyvary-based syndicate in 2001 has no entitlement to any money. Now, Martin Horan of Carragown, Bohola, Castlebar, faces the prospect of a legal bill which could run to hundreds of thousands of euro, while the other four members of the syndicate will each share in the €400,000 which has been on deposit in a Post Office Account since the €2 million win.

Mr Justice Frank Clarke, in a High Court decision in December 2004, ruled that Mr Horan was entitled to a one-fifth share of the prize and also awarded costs estimated at some €100,000 to Mr Horan against the other four members of the syndicate.

This decision was overturned on appeal yesterday (Monday) by the three-judge Supreme Court, consisting of Presiding Judge Mr Justice Hugh Geoghegan, along with Mr Justice Niall Fennelly and Mr Justice Joseph Finnegan. The appeal hinged on whether or not Mr Horan was still a member of the syndicate which won the Lotto on January 6 2001, because he had last made a payment towards the cost of playing the game in October 2000.

The other members of the syndicate – Frank O’Reilly, a publican, of O’Reilly’s pub, Ballyvary, Castlebar; Michael McHale, a farmer, of Curranee, Ballyvary; John Joyce, a taxi driver from Keelogues, Ballyvary; and Seamus O’Brien, also a taxi driver, of Ballyvary – contended that they had excluded Mr Horan from continuing to be a member, and accordingly, had reduced the amount they played on the Lotto each week by £1.50. The Supreme Court held yesterday that this was a clear indication that Mr Horan was no longer a member of the syndicate, and upheld the appeal.

It was Mr Horan’s case that he had always been allowed to fall into arrears in the syndicate – which was formed nine years ago – and would catch up on payments with one lump sum.

However, the Supreme Court also found that the original agreement that existed between the five men only permitted those who had paid their stake to share in any winnings, and that this agreement could not be changed without the consent of all members of the syndicate.

Allowing the appeal, the court also awarded costs for the High Court and Supreme Court hearings against Mr Horan.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice