Boating tragedy widow refused permission to build in native Mayo village


Mayo County Council says Marian Doherty, a native of Achill, failed to demonstrate a clear need to return to live in her home village
AN Achill native whose husband and nephew died in a boating tragedy in 2018 was refused planning permission by Mayo County Council to return home to build on family land.
Marian Doherty was refused planning permission by Mayo County Council to construct a 'modest' single storey dwelling house in Keel West, Dooagh on Achill Island after planners judged it the development would constitute 'haphazard development in a rural area'.
In her application, Ms Doherty, who resides in Co Donegal, revealed that she grew up in Dooagh but emigrated to Scotland for work purposes and eventually settled in Co Donegal. She claimed 'my life hit a standstill' after the death of her husband and her nephew in a boating tragedy and she wants to return to Achill Island.
Her husband Gerry Doherty and her 16-year-old nephew Thomas Weir both died in a boating tragedy off the coast of Malin Head in Co Donegal in July 2018.
“My family are grown now with their own families and I would again love to return to Dooagh where my siblings are. It was always our intention to return to Dooagh however life had a different plan. I hold so many happy memories of growing up and living in Dooagh and I ask for planning to be considered so that I can return and live out my days there,” she stated in a letter to the council.
Her brother, John Gielty provided a site for her to build a ‘modest’ two-bedroom house and Ms Doherty stated she chose the site to lessen the visual impact of the proposed house. She added she has no other suitable site to locate a house.
However, planners with Mayo County Council expressed reservation regarding the application stating that she had not ‘demonstrated a clear need to locate to this area'. They also expressed doubt regarding the access road to the site saying it was very narrow and bendy with a stream adjacent.
“It is also stated that ‘considering the nature, use and width of the adjoining public road it is considered that a realistic actual speed on this narrow public road would be 20 kph as it is impractical to drive in speeds in excess of 20kph,” the planner wrote in the report.
Planning permission for the house was refused by Mayo County Council who stated that the applicant had failed to demonstrate a clear need to locate in an area along a scenic route and granting permission would be a contravention of the Mayo County Development Plan.
“The proposed development if permitted would, both by itself and the precedent it would set, interfere with the character of the rural landscape which it is necessary to protect, and be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area,” the planners concluded.
