Ballina men jailed for assault
Four young Ballina men were jailed last week for their part in a vicious unprovoked assault which took place on the streets of the north Mayo two two and a half years ago.
Young Ballina men receive lengthy jail terms after assualt
FOUR young Ballina men were jailed last week for their part in a vicious unprovoked assault which took place on the streets of the north Mayo town two-and-a-half years ago.
Mr Kevin Cafferty (22) of 19 Millview Crescent, Ballina; Mr Kevin Tighe (20) of Quay Road, Ballina, and Mr Keelan McHale (18) of 120 Greenhills Estate, Ballina all received a term of three years in prison for assault causing harm, while Mr McHale received a further year in prison for intimidating a prosecution witness in the case. A fourth young man, a 17-year-old, was remanded in custody until the April sittings of the court when Judge Raymond Groarke said he would reconsider the matter due to the defendant’s young age, as he was only 14 years old when the assault took place. All four pleaded guilty to the assault of Stephen Gillespie, Claire Gillespie and Niamh Howley on July 13, 2006,
Judge Raymond Groarke said this was a very sad day for four young men who were in court pleading guilty to assault causing harm. He said they were probably decent young men but the prospect they faced was nothing compared to what their victims had gone through since the assaults on July 13, 2006.
The judge said their main victim, Stephen Gillespie, will forever be reminded of the day he met with the four men and their friends, when he had just been out for a drink with his sister and girlfriend on Heritage Day in Ballina.
The court had heard previously that Mr Gillespie had been out of work for six months, suffered a detached retina and fractured eye socket, and had to wear glasses permanently to see now, having previously had perfect sight in both eyes. He told the court he went through ‘excruciating’ pain that he would not wish on anybody and continued to take medication to control the side-effects of the assault and the physical pain and discomfort he still endures.
The judge said last week that of course Mr Gillespie was angry, he was entitled to be, but he had got on with life after it had been turned upside down due to the actions of these men.
The judge said that in sentencing he could not ignore the fact that these were young men but he could not get away from the fact that these men made a voluntary decision to take part in this assault and violent disorder. The three victims were just out for a night out when they were spotted by this group, who were spitting, hissing and shouting.
Judge Groarke said the astonishing feature of the case for him was the lack of explanation for the men’s actions. He said he was now convinced there was no reason as to why 20 people had got involved in criminal conduct. He had to assume that there was no reason as none had been brought before him in mitigation.
“That simply means that it could have been anyone that was attacked. It could have been me, it could have been you, it could have been your mother, your father, your son, your daughter,” said Judge Groarke, who said the whole case reminded him of a television advert from some years back, where a family’s pet dog was shown first being patted by his owner at home on a mat in front of the fire, before he was let outside at night. The dog then wandered off and met up with other dogs and proceeded to savage a sheep.
“I have no doubt that these are four decent, respectable men when they are with their families but it’s different, things change when they are part of the gang; the pack goes wild and woe betide anyone that comes in their way.”
Judge Groarke said in sentencing he had to pay attention to the ‘cardinal rules’ which were to punish a wrongdoer and to let it be seen that sentencing is a deterrent to others who might stop and think of the consequences of their actions.
He said in this case it was very difficult to balance the punishment with the possibility of rehabilitation. However, he did not want to be a judge that was viewed to be soft on crime. He said he did feel sorry for the parents and families of the four young men but he had to impose the custodial sentences previously mentioned. The judge refused leave to appeal on the grounds of severity.
Before sentencing, the judge had heard from the mother of Kevin Cafferty, Mary Cafferty, who said her son’s actions on the night were totally out of character. Mr John McLoughlin, a friend of the Tighe family, said he had secured a place on a residential programme for Kevin Tighe, who was willing to address his problem with alcohol.
Detective Garda Leo Heaney also told the court of the evidence which led to Keelan McHale facing a charge of intimidating a witness. It occurred on June 15, 2008 when a prosecution witness, Stephen Hughes, was approached by McHale while he was sitting in his car. Mr McHale said to Mr Hughes to withdraw his statement and to say that Garda Leo Heaney had forced him into making it. Mr McHale denied he had intimidated Mr Hughes but CCTV footage had shown him approaching Mr Hughes’ car on the day in question.