Ballina men jailed after an assault
TWO Ballina men who assaulted two other men in the forecourt of a filling station had prison sentences imposed on them, at the local District Court last week.
Ballina men jailed after assault on two men at filling station forecourt
TWO Ballina men who assaulted two other men in the forecourt of a filling station had prison sentences imposed on them, at the local District Court last week.
Mr Paddy Collins and Mr Martin Collins, both of 17 Fenian Row, Ballina, were convicted in relation to an incident which happened at a forecourt on the Foxford Road, Ballina on March 24 last between 4am and 5am. Each had pleaded guilty to the charges.
The court was told by Garda Michael Munnelly that when he arrived at the scene he found one of the injured parties, Oisin Murphy, lying unconscious on the ground. He said he was bleeding from the left side of his head. A second man, Vincent McDonnell, told Garda Munnelly that he had also been the victim of an assault.
Garda Munnelly said Paddy Collins and Martin Collins were both at the scene when he arrived. Garda Munnelly said he looked at the CCTV footage and he saw Paddy Collins assaulting Vincent McDonnell. He also saw Martin Collins standing over Oisin Murphy as he lay on the ground.
Garda Munnelly outlined to Judge Mary Devins the background to the incident. He said a car, in which the injured parties were travelling, had stopped for petrol when a car carrying Martin Collins pulled up alongside. A man got out to fill petrol and he was smoking a cigarette. After being asked to stop smoking by Vincent McDonnell, because of the proximity to the petrol pumps, a row ensued and words were exchanged.
At the same time Paddy Collins arrived at the scene in another car and, on seeing the row, got out of the car and assaulted Vincent McDonnell. Martin Collins then hit Oisin Murphy one blow and knocked him to the ground.
Defending solicitor, Mr Alan Gannon, said Paddy Collins had arrived separately at the scene and, on seeing what was going on, he foolishly over-reacted. He said he was a man in his mid-twenties who was unemployed and lived with his parents. He was due to get married next year. He said he entirely mis-interpreted what was going on at the forecourt when he arrived.
Mr Gannon said Martin Collins was 20 years of age and had never been in trouble before. After he assaulted Oisin Murphy he realised the seriousness of what had happened and the fracas stopped. He said his client had called the ambulance after seeing the injured party lying on the ground unconscious.
In relation to Paddy Collins, Judge Devins was told that he had 20 previous convictions, including two for assault. Judge Devins imposed a fine of €500 for the Section 2 assault charge and directed that he pay €500 in compensation. She also sentenced him to three months’ imprisonment.
Martin Collins was fined €750 for the Section 3 assault and directed to pay €750 towards Oisin Murphy as compensation. He as also sentenced to 28 days’ imprisonment.
Recognisances were fixed in both instances in the event of an appeal.