Anybody there, I ask myself
SONIA KELLY “We can’t all get to be President, or even to be a Mafia boss, so most of us have to make do with more insignificant signs”
Anybody there, I ask myself
I suppose most people will have experienced those moments when you seem to stand outside yourself and wonder who’s inside. Me? Me, you think questioningly and hope something clicks.
Having a name helps to ground one, as it were, and that’s why it’s reassuring when people use it – as if it’s proof that you exist. For somebody to have known your father ... your grandfather is even better proof, which explains the importance of lineage.
Some societies are really big into this and maybe it indicates a certain insecurity. In order to get married, for instance, a recognisable descent has to be on view, whereas confident people like Americans are quite sure of their existence and can easily dispense with fathers. Even they like to feel important, though, because that boosts the feeling of being, and importance means that you can affect the life of at least one other person. The more lives you can affect, the more obvious it must be that somebody is actually there, doing the affecting.
But we can’t all get to be President, or even to be a Mafia boss, so most of us have to make do with more insignificant signs. Even saying ‘thank you’ to someone is telling them that they’ve made a difference – have affected your life in some way, so they must really exist. To give a present is providing stronger proof – proof that they matter – are important.
So the degree to which you can make changes is the measure of your importance – so it seems. Hence the lure of a political role. It doesn’t matter too much if the changes are good or bad so long as they are noticeable and if you get to be really powerful you can build a monument to make sure that future generations have proof that you did once exist.
But to get back to everyday life and the comfort that being recognised bestows on people – it behoves one to address others by name and it’s really unfortunate if, like myself, you frequently forget who they are. Or, worse still, use the wrong one. In this case, a warm smile is the best substitute – and such a gesture does not go amiss, even if strangers are involved. It shows, at least, that you can see they are there. This is the reason one’s home town is such a reassuring place: so many people greet one, smile, see one. Whereas, in an alien place, one is invisible, ie does not exist.
I wonder if cave men had names. Did they smile? If not, when did these customs and expressions come into being? Presumably not until such time as the question of identity arose, or until people first looked inside and wondered who was there. Now that genetic research is revealing how we inherit our predecessors’ make-up, it is beginning to look as if we are, after all, immortal and that the apposite question is not ‘is anyone there?’ but ‘who’s there?’.
This is extremely worrying. I have a lot of ancestors who would cause me to be stoned to death if recognised. The Scottish branch of my family actually turned out to be so infamous that a cousin who was researching them lost the courage to proceed. And there are stories of a curse being put on one progenitor in India, which may account for the way I never win anything and, in fact, for the way I have been teetering on the bread line for as long as I can remember.
Some lucky people, of course, have worthy ancestors – great warriors and kings and athletes – whose reincarnated faces may peer out at them from mirrors and give them a sense of identify and that’s OK, but others like me are left wondering what exactly we consist of, and preferring not to know. Just basically relying on smiles and greetings to provide a sense of reality.