An unwelcome guest

placeholder image

The appointment of a Protestant librarian in County Mayo in 1930 generated no small amount of controversy.

“Letitia Dunbar Harrison was unacceptable to the group because she was a Protestant and educated at Trinity College. The majority of the members of the sub-committee did not believe she could be trusted with providing a proper library service for the Catholic people of Mayo”

Second Reading

Letitia was born in Dublin in 1906. A Protestant, she was educated at Alexandra College and Trinity. She graduated from the university with an honours degree in French and Spanish. After graduation she trained as a librarian at Dublin County Library Headquarters. Later she worked in the Rathmines Public Library, where she specialised in children’s books. She also took a summer course in library techniques at UCD.

In 1930, she applied for one of the five county librarian positions advertised and was appointed to Mayo. Since the foundation of the State proficiency in Irish was a requirement for public service positions. She did not have the required standard of Irish but the legislation allowed an office-holder three years to acquire it.

Her appointment took place under the aegis of the Local Appointments Commission. This body had been established in 1926 to ensure fairness in public appointments. Once an appointment was made by the commission, statutory bodies, like Mayo County Council, were obliged to ratify it.

That is not how it was seen in Mayo. In November, 1930, the Mayo Library Committee, a sub-committee of the County Council, composed mainly of Catholic clerics, rejected Letitia Dunbar Harrison’s nomination as county librarian.

Why were Catholic clerics so dominant on the committee? The Catholic Church, in the early decades of the new Irish state, was determined to shape and control the moral environment. Within this mind frame, books were seen as a possible source of spiritual contamination. This view is clearly expressed in the Lenten pastoral of Archbishop Gilmartin of Tuam in 1931:

“The modern world is teeming with all kinds of printed matter, books, more especially novels, reviews, magazines, papers – a few of them good, some of them indifferent, some of them positively immoral, and many of them illustrated with indecent pictures.”

The ostensible reason given by the sub-committee for its rejection of Miss Dunbar Harrison’s appointment was that she did not have Irish. As Mayo had a number of Gaeltacht communities, they deemed this an essential requirement.

A reading of the debate at the sub-committee meeting, however, reveals the real reasons for its decision. Letitia Dunbar Harrison was unacceptable to the group because she was a Protestant and educated at Trinity College. The majority of the members of the sub-committee did not believe she could be trusted with providing a proper library service for the Catholic people of Mayo.

One cleric called her a ‘West Briton’, a pejorative term. He asserted that ‘the people who have assigned her to Catholic and Nationalist Mayo have made a very serious mistake. The business of government is to promote the good of the community to fall in with the general idea of the country’. Another cleric claimed she would have ‘the mental outlook and constitution’ of Trinity College, which he categorised as anti-Irish.

At its meeting in December, 1930, Mayo County Council voted to accept the sub-committee’s rejection of Miss Dunbar Harrison. The county secretary, MJ Egan, warned councillors that they were acting illegally. The Minister for Local Government, Richard Mulcahy, did likewise and gave the Council until the end of the year to reverse its decision. MJ Egan called an emergency meeting of the Council for December 27 at which councillors refused to change their original verdict. Richard Mulcahy abolished the Council on December 31 and appointed a Commissioner, PJ Bartley, to carry out its functions. One of his first acts was to appoint Letitia Dunbar Harrison as librarian.

His decision did not end the affair. Soon after her arrival in Castlebar, Miss Dunbar Harrison faced a boycott of library services, organised by clerics and conservative Catholics. By June, only four of the 122 library centres in the county were in operation. Most centres returned their books.

Cumann na nGaedheal politicians in Mayo came under severe pressure to force the Government to end the librarian’s tenure and restore the county council. The Fianna Fáil party, anxious to exploit the situation for political gain, supported the protests.

Under this pressure, Mayo Cumann na nGaedheal TDs tabled a motion in the Dáil in June, 1931 opposing the reading of a bill granting more power to the Minister for Local Government unless he restored Mayo County Council. After some unease the Government survived.

President Cosgrave, however, was anxious to resolve the situation as a general election was pending. Cumann na nGaedheal had up to then the support of many Catholic bishops and priests. He feared that the party was in danger of forfeiting this support. By the autumn of the year Miss Dunbar Harrison accepted a transfer to the library of the Department of Defence at a higher remuneration.

She found little welcome in Mayo. But she did experience some warmth in the cold atmosphere of Castlebar. She fell in love with the local Methodist minister, Rev Robert Crawford, whom she later married.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice