An open letter to Minister Eamon Ryan


Dear Minister Ryan, you met Willie Corduff before. You did not see him last week when he was treated in hospital.
Dear Minister Ryan,
YOU met Willie Corduff before. You did not see him last week when he was treated at the Mayo General Hospital after he was attacked by men in balaclavas inside Shell’s compound in Glengad. The same night another balaclava-clad group broke in from the outside, causing considerable damage and injuring a security guard. Willie Corduff’s story was generally ignored by the mainstream media. You met Willie a few weeks ago during the recent discussions on Corrib with your colleague Minister Éamon Ó’Cuív and Shell personnel.
You were also present at the Four Courts when he was released with four friends (the Rossport Five) after spending over 90 days in prison. You gladly paraded in front of the cameras with your party colleagues, John Gormley and Trevor Sargent to herald their release. Back then, you were in verbal overdrive calling for the Corrib Gas project to be revisited. You promised as much if the Green Party came into power. You are now, but Corrib is obviously too high octane for the lungs of the Green Party.
You have been challenged before about your inept handling of publicising your decisions in relation to Corrib. Such carelessness adds to the tinderbox that the Corrib project now is. Your recent permission to Shell to carry out works in Glengad was not only reckless but borders on the irresponsible. In Tullamore last week you said: “We have to stick to the rule of law.” Thankfully, you included yourself in that statement.
Why did you ask a departmental official to write to Mayo County Council seeking justification for your decision some two weeks after you gave Shell permission to work on Glengad?
Local people’s questions are echoed in a formal complaint about your action from An Taisce regarding your ‘back-up letter.’ This letter, which you passed on to the media, begs further questions. You claim the works at Glengad are ‘exempted development.’ You cite Class 25 of the Planning & Development Regulations 2001, Schedule 2 Part1: “the construction of an underground pipeline is exempted development under that class.”
You fail to quote the next section in the regulation that states: “…but not the construction or erection of any apparatus, equipment or other thing ancillary to such a pipeline save cathodic equipment and marker posts.”
You also cite Class 16 of the Regulation, stating: “Such ancillary works necessary for carrying out of exempted development are in themselves exempted development under that class.” Again you are selective. You fail to state that a development can only be carried out “in pursuant to a permission under the Planning & Development Act.” This means that ‘exempted work’ can only be carried out if a planning permission has already been granted. It also states that all ancillary works are exempted “but not the construction or erection of any apparatus, equipment or other thing ancillary to such a pipeline.” There is no planning permission in place for works at the site.
Glengad is the landfall for the offshore pipeline. This comes under An Bord Pleanála as a Strategic Infrastructure project, not Mayo County Council. Shell has applied to ABP. An oral hearing is due next month with a decision due in August, at the earliest.
Further proof of your incompetence is found in the action of Bord Gáis Éireann. During the construction of the Mayo-Galway gas pipeline, BGE always applied to the respective planning authority in Mayo or Galway for planning permission to erect construction compounds. Why are you treating Shell differently?
In doing so, you are only adding to the angst of many local people in north Mayo whose lives have been so badly affected by a project that has wrought nothing but sorrow and strife on them.
Have the Greens ‘sacrificed’ Corrib on the altar of power? Regardless of the numerous trans-national insensitivities of Shell, and they are legion, what the Irish Government continues to do to this community borders on betrayal. You are continuing that trend. It is an ongoing collusion of incompetence. Shame on you Minister. Willie Corduff and Erris people, do they matter?
Sincerely,
Liamy MacNally