‘Major gaps in evidence’ leads to open verdict

THE driver of a car involved in a traffic accident, which resulted in the death of a Westport-based Italian restaurant owner, said he would not offer an explanation as to why he left the scene by travelling back to Westport through fields.

‘Major gaps in evidence’ leads to open verdict

THE driver of a car involved in a traffic accident, which resulted in the death of a Westport-based Italian restaurant owner, said he would not offer an explanation as to why he left the scene by travelling back to Westport through fields.

Mr Angelo Forcina (33), the proprietor of ‘La Bella Vita’ restaurant in Westport, died instantly following the accident at approximately 12.30am on July17, 2006, at Ballydonnellan along the Ballinrobe road – two-and-a-half miles from Westport. Mr Forcina’s Mitsubishi jeep collided with a Toyota MR2 driven by Mr Patrick Ryder, which resulted in both vehicles rolling over and ending up 110 yards from each other.

Last week. an open verdict was recorded at the inquest into the death of Mr Forcina, who had an address at Cooloughra, Ardogommon, Ballinrobe Road, Westport, and was a native of Latina, Italy. Superintendent Pat Doyle said he could not make head nor tail of the carnage on the road, adding that it was the most horrific traffic accident he had seen in 35 years as a garda.

Mr Forcina was only 1.1km from his home when the accident occurred and died instantly after receiving multiple fatal injuries, including massive haemorrhaging to the lung and liver. A blood alcohol test following his post mortem found that he had 84mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood.

Mr Ryder, a train driver with an address at Tavanaghmore, Foxford, told the inquest that, at 5pm on July 16, he finished work and went for a meal with his friend, Joe Davis, and his parents. He said that he and Mr Davis then went to a few pubs in Westport but he claimed he had only one pint.

He said they went for a spin in his Toyota car and and when they were returning to Westport he claimed all he remembered was a blinding flash of light. He said he realised the car was upside down and feared the car would go on fire. He said he remembered walking with Mr Davis in a field and ending up at his house in Westport.

Mr Ryder said when he was told by a friend that a person had died in the accident, he went to Westport Garda Station at 5.50am. He said he met with Garda Michael Clarke, who started to take a statement from him, but claimed he was told by the garda he was not in a fit state to make a statement. He said he  had no further recollection of what happened. Because of the injuries he sustained he had not gone back to work.

When asked by the coroner, Mr John O’Dwyer, why he chose to walk through the fields rather than on the road, Mr Ryder said he had been trying to ‘rationalise that for the last two years’.

During the inquest, Ms Bebhinn Langan said she saw two men coming out of the MR2 and both were injured and disorientated. She said there was a lot of debris and when she went towards the jeep she saw a body near the ditch on the road. Ms Langan said the two men came towards the body and she heard them say, ‘please wake up’, and claimed both of them nudged the body with their feet.

Mr Thomas Muldoon Jnr said he was lying in bed at about 12.25am when he heard a screech of tyres outside his house and a clip on the bank on the side of the road. He looked out the window and saw a red MR2 on the wrong side of the road facing towards Westport. He said the car moved forward, correcting itself on the right side of the roadway, and approximately 20 seconds later he heard what he thought was a clap of thunder.

Garda Brian Kilkelly, who attended the scene, said that both vehicles were extensively damaged and there was a lot of debris on the road, including some attached to the tree branches. He said both vehicles rolled over before stopping and he believed that Mr Forcina’s vehicle became airborne after impact and he was thrown from the vehicle.

Garda Dave Healy, PSV inspector and Forensic Collision Examiner, said the point of impact was in the centre of the road and from his investigations he was satisfied that the driver of the MR2 was responsible for the collision. He said the MR2 was pulling over from the incorrect side of the road when it was hit by the jeep, but added he did not know why the jeep did not brake.

Garda Healy said that because of the damage to the vehicles he could not determine the speed at which the vehicles were travelling but stated that there was no doubt that speed was involved and ‘primarily on behalf of the jeep’.

Under questioning from Mr Boguslaw McArdle, solicitor for Mr Forcina’s family, Mr Ryder said he could not remember the incident Mr Muldoon described and would not say if it was him. He said he did not recollect meeting Ms Langan or asking the deceased if he was okay.

In relation to the incident described by Ms Langan, Mr Davis said if it happened ‘it happened’ but claimed he could not remember it. He denied the incident described by Mr Muldoon, saying that the car was never out of control. Mr Davis said he remembered everything up until the accident but was in shock afterwards.

Mr O’Dwyer said there was a clear conflict between the evidence of Ms Langan and Mr Muldoon and of Mr Davis and Mr Ryder. He said that for some reason Mr Davis and Mr Ryder were not fully aware of what occurred and because there were major gaps in the evidence and no other witness was able to give evidence of what occurred, he recommended to the jury that they record an open verdict.

After the jury recorded an open verdict, Mr O’Dwyer extended his sympathy to Mr Forcina’s family, his partner Anneli Watson and their young son, and hoped they would find the strength to carry the cross and uphold his memory. Mr Rory O’Connor, solicitor for Mr Ryder, said his client wished to extend his sympathy to Ms Watson, while Mr McArdle said that Mr Davis held out his hand to Ms Watson and stated that ‘he knew what he was doing’.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice