Achill man overturns refusal of hackney licence

In the District Court, an Achill man has successfully appealed the decision not to grant him a Local Area Hackney Licence

Achill man succeeds in challenge to refusal of hackney licence

 

Landmark decision finds that Achill transport needs not adequately met

An Achill man has successfully appealed the non-granting of a Local Area Hackney Licence (LAHL).

John Martin Gallagher of Dookinella, Achill, had applied for the licence from the National Transport Authority but was refused. He subsequently appealed that decision to the District Court and at last Thursday’s sitting of Achill District Court Judge Mary Devins ruled in his favour.

A LAHL is easier and cheaper to obtain than a standard hackney or taxi licence. According to the NTA’s website, they can only issue a LAHL ‘where it is satisfied that the public transport needs of the area in respect of which the licence is sought are not being adequately met by existing public transport services, including existing SPSV services, and that the local public transport demands merit same’.

Judge Devins described Achill Island as being ‘like a goose’ in that there is too much work for one current taxi on the island, operated by John Patrick McGinty, but not enough work for two full licences and therefore the need for a LAHL was there.

The case was first heard at Achill District Court in April where Wendy Thompson, the Head of Taxi Regulation from the NTA, gave evidence of why they had refused the application.

She told the court that they felt Achill was adequately served by existing transport between Bus Éireann and one taxi and four minibus services.

Investigating

Ms Thompson told the court that she checked names of operators advertised beside a payphone in the hotel she was staying in the previous night and said this showed some who were not registered with the NTA, which they were investigating.

The court heard Mayo County Council had told the NTA there was a need for a LAHL in Achill, as part of Mr Gallagher’s application.

Giving evidence at the first sitting of the court, John Martin Gallagher said the minibuses operating in Achill were all 16 seaters or larger and were too big for a lot of taxi jobs. He disputed the NTA’s assertion about the number of minibuses operating in Achill, saying two of them were no longer in business.

Before the end of the court Kathleen O’Riordan came to court to give evidence that herself and her husband’s business was no longer operating and the court was told of another operator who had also ceased trading.

He said he would only be operating the LAHL on a part-time basis and the profits would be marginal.

The only existing taxi licence holder in Achill, John Patrick McGinty, gave evidence outlining the need for an additional Licence. The court heard he and Mr Gallagher plan to work together and Mr McGinty would pass on trade to Mr Gallagher when he is already booked. Mr McArdle argued that the service provided by Bus Éireann on Achill was wholly inadequate.

Eoin Garavan, for the NTA, said there are 312 hackney and taxis in Mayo and only two LAHL, one in Derrada, Newport and another in north Mayo. He said the motor tax and licence costs are much cheaper for LAHLs and the licence runs for three years, compared to just one for a standard hackney or taxi.

LAHL holders do not have to sit the same courses either, Mr Garavan said.

Solicitor for  the defendant, Bob McArdle, argued that there was a much better provision of transport in Derrada, Newport, than there was in Achill and the licence should be given.

Judge Mary Devins adjourned the matter to last Thursday to consider a number of issues.

Obstructive

Last Thursday Eoin Garavan argued that Mr Gallagher could apply for a conventional taxi licence and made reference to the fact that Mr Gallagher had sat and failed the local area knowledge test on four occasions. This was countered by Bob McArdle who said his client was ‘not happy’ with a number of matters brought up by the NTA and may apply to the Data Protection Commissioner about how the case was handled by the NTA.

In her ruling Judge Devins said the original spirit of the LAHL was to facilitate a low cost entry for a hackney in rural areas otherwise unlikely to have such services.

She said that instead of facilitating applicants like John Martin Gallagher, the National Transport Authority ‘appears to come close to being as obstructive as possible’ and ruled in Mr Gallagher’s favour.

Eoin Garavan said this was the first time such a case had been before the courts and the judgement would give the NTA guidelines for future reference.

An application for the awarding of costs in Mr Gallagher’s favour was adjourned to October 1.

 

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice