A model Taoiseach


I believe that Jack Lynch was the most gracious, modest and dignified person to occupy the office of Taoiseach in the history of the State. In the words of WB Yeats, in courtesy he was ‘chiefly learned’.
“Unlike de Valera, Lynch was never a divisive figure. Liam Cosgrave reckoned he was the most popular Irish politician since Daniel O’Connell. Garret FitzGerald found him ‘impossible to oppose’”
Second Reading
So the news that a new bishop for the diocese of Killala was to be ordained in St Muredach’s Cathedral seemed quite exciting. The Western People announced that the Taoiseach, Jack Lynch, and Cardinal Conway were to attend the ceremony. At last, we would glimpse in the flesh people we had seen only on television.
I remember going with a group of friends to the Cathedral, in the thickening twilight of a December Sunday, to see what was happening. Cardinal Conway emerged from the sacristy, draped in a scarlet cloak, and glided urgently to his car. He dismissed our request for autographs with a wave of his hands. It was hard to blame him. It had begun to drizzle heavily.
In contrast, Jack Lynch stood and talked to us. He signed our notebooks. He told us that the most successful Mayo football captain ever, Seán Flanagan, was a member of his government. He enquired whether there was any hurling in Mayo. We said no. We knew nothing of the lonely exploits of Tooreen. One lad asked him whether he had played himself. He modestly admitted he had, this man whose name was legend in the glorious annals of Cork GAA.
A little encounter, but character is often most clearly revealed when no one important is looking. I believe that Jack Lynch was the most gracious, modest and dignified person to occupy the office of Taoiseach in the history of the State. In the words of WB Yeats, in courtesy he was ‘chiefly learned’.
In terms of elections won with clear-cut majorities, he was the most successful Fianna Fáil leader since de Valera. Unlike de Valera, he was never a divisive figure. Liam Cosgrave reckoned he was the most popular Irish politician since Daniel O’Connell. Garret FitzGerald found him ‘impossible to oppose’.
In his constituency in Cork, he was the uncrowned king, or the ‘real’ Taoiseach, whether in or out of office. Pat Magner, the Labour Party activist, recalled how he tried to undermine a constituent’s faith in Lynch by showing her a photograph of the Taoiseach in full morning dress in the company of some oil company executives. “There you are now, mam,” said Magner to an old neighbour of Lynch, as he stepped over the basin that gathered water from her leaking roof. “There’s Jack for you”. She looked at the photograph and said: “Ah Jesus, will you look at him. Didn’t he come on grand.”
After his resignation as Taoiseach, Jack Lynch was largely airbrushed out of history. The country was engulfed in the sulphurous dramas of the Haughey era. Amends are now being made. Recently, the Department of History at University College Cork, hosted a conference, ‘Jack Lynch: Politics and Sport, Personality and Leadership’, which assessed his record in government from the 1950s to the 1970s.
Even if Lynch never attained political eminence he would have a place in history because of his sporting prowess. He belongs to the elite group of players who have won All-Ireland medals in hurling and football. He is the only player in GAA history to have won six All-Irelands in a row – five hurling and one football.
According to Con Murphy, a contemporary, he had great flexibility as a player, a ‘quick thinker’ on the field and a ‘good reader’ of the game. He never started foul play but opponents who fouled him discovered it made him play better. It was a characteristic that followed him to politics as Charles Haughey and Neil Blaney found in 1970.
Lynch practised as a barrister before winning a seat in the Dáil in 1948. He held a succession of senior ministries – Education, Industry and Commerce and Finance – before emerging as the compromise candidate to succeed Seán Lemass as Taoiseach in 1966.
His achievements as Taoiseach were threefold. According to Jonathan Bardon, a Queen’s University historian, his handling of the Northern Irish troubles was the most crucial contribution to the preservation of democracy in the Republic since de Valera overcame the Blueshirts and the IRA in the thirties. He showed courage and political skill in his dismissal of Charles Haughey and Neil Blaney from the cabinet for allegedly using government money to import arms for use by the IRA in Northern Ireland. He convinced the Fianna Fáil party to accept that the border could only be removed by peaceful means. He challenged Irish nationalist society to understand the history, perceptions and fears of Unionists.
Secondly, he persuaded the British government to accept that the Republic had a legitimate interest in the affairs of Northern Ireland and so paved the tortuous path to the peace process.
Thirdly, he convinced the electorate to vote overwhelmingly in favour of our entry into the EEC (now the EU), a development which, despite the sour arguments of many opponents of the Lisbon Treaty, has had a hugely positive influence on our society.
It has to be said that Lynch’s last term as Taoiseach was, comparatively, not a success. The Fianna Fáil election manifesto of 1977 was irresponsible in its promises and helped ensure that our experience of the late seventies recession lasted well into the eighties.
After Charles Huaghey’s election as Fianna Fáil leader in 1979, a journalist spotted Jack Lynch walking alone to his office, the cheers of the victors ringing in his ears. The future had begun and it did not include him. He could, however, comfort himself with the knowledge that, in the words of Andrew Marvell, he nothing common did or mean in the memorable scenes of his political life.