A different society
Second Reading Last week ‘The Guardian’ carried a horrific report on the phenomenon of female suicide in Turkey.
“In our society, with its aggressive emphasis on success in work, personal appearance and social prestige, many feel alienated and filled with personal anxiety.”
Second Reading
Fr Kevin Hegarty
Last week ‘The Guardian’ carried a horrific report on the phenomenon of female suicide in Turkey. In Batman, a city of 250,000, more than 300 women have attempted suicide since 2001. Seven died in one month alone. Some have jumped from rooftops or cut their wrists.
Nuran Uca is one victim. She had fallen in love with a man whose family thought the relationship was dishonourable. “She was modern and wore tight clothes, which is why his family rejected her. She was banned by her parents from seeing or speaking to him, and then they stopped her leaving the house. In the end the pressure was too much.”
Women’s groups and human rights advocates believe that suicides can be more adequately described as murders. Ayetkin Sir, a psychiatrist who has studied the trend claims that “there is a lot of evidence that these are, in fact, honour killings passed off as suicides – that these girls are being forced to take their lives.”
Young women who offend against the mores of extreme Islam are compelled to resort to suicide. It is easy for women to cause offence and bring so called ‘dishonour’ to their families. The list of ‘offences’ is long: rape, incest, pregnancy outside marriage, ringing a radio chat show, exchanging eye contact with a man or wearing skimpy clothing. A villager near Diyarbakir telescoped chillingly the attitude of his community. “Without rules you have chaos. If my sister or mother made a mistake, we men would have to make it right. They would have to pay to cleanse our honour.”
Turkey is a foreign country. They do things differently there. It is a society caught acutely in the conflict between tradition and modernity. Suicide, however, is a worldwide phenomenon, riven by cultural complexities. Last week, a five day international suicide prevention congress in Killarney brought this point home.
August is, traditionally, the silly season in the media, but the news from Killarney was serious. There are about one million deaths from suicide around the world every year with one person taking their own life every 45 seconds.
How does Ireland stand? We experienced one of the fastest growing rates of suicide in the world in the 1980’s and 1990’s. The overall suicide rate doubled over that period. Between 2000 and 2002 there were, on average, 494 deaths by suicide. According to Dr Carol Fitzpatrick, professor of child psychiatry at University College Dublin, children as young as six years are presenting to hospital having attempted suicide. The rate of youth suicide in Ireland is the fifth highest in the European Union. Men under the age of 35 account for 40% of all Irish suicides.
Why is this happening? Suicide is a complex and poorly understood problem. Some argue that a by-product of the flowering of feminist consciousness in recent decades has, in some instances, been a corrosive contempt for men. A feminist writer, Doris Lessing, has even lent her voice to this argument. Though she does not claim that the equality movement has gone too far or that it has realised all its objectives, she makes the point that it is now socially acceptable to consider men domestically incompetent, inadequate fathers and unreliable breadwinners. Men, it seems, according to her, have lost an empire and not gained a role.
Feelings of uselessness can lead to depression, drug abuse, alcoholism, violence and crime. They can also lead to despair and despair is the main ingredient in the poisonous cocktail that provokes suicide.
There may be something in her argument. The answer is not in returning to a society where men were dominant. See what that has caused in Turkey. The challenge, rather, for society is to foster self confidence, self worth and respect in all its young men and women.
Her argument, however, hardly explains the high rate of suicide among older men in rural Ireland. The social supports that underpin rural societies are collapsing. Farming, as an economic endeavour, has lost its viability, for most small farmers. Village life is losing its internal cohesion.
This is part of a European pattern. Seven years ago, Geert Mak, a Dutch writer, wrote a book on a village in the Netherlands, Jorwerd, that evokes what is happening throughout Western Europe. In 1995, the Netherlands had the most intensive agriculture in Europe but less than 2 percent of its people had anything to do with farming. With machines one man can milk 100 cows on his own. Farmers who cannot keep up with technological innovation sell out their land and milk quotas to bigger factory farms. Or to developers intent on building more bungalow parks or yachting marinas.
By 1995 one third of Dutch villages no longer had a grocery shop, a quarter are no longer on a bus route. At night one police car may cover more than fifty villages. The rate of change in Ireland may be slower but we are getting there. Witness the closure of rural post offices, schools, garda stations and churches.
As Fr Harry Bohan argued at a Teagasc conference in Athenry last week “gone are the days of communal activities such as saving the hay and spending days in the bog and instead farmers have become isolated in a short space of time”. Mass production of crops with a high level of pesticides has solved the problem of food production but at enormous social and biological cost.
This social breakdown is leading to isolation, depression and loneliness – all signposts to suicide. In our society, with its aggressive emphasis on success in work, personal appearance and social prestige, many feel alienated and filled with personal anxiety.
Under the brash exterior of our current economic success, Ireland is, in the words of Seamus Heaney, “full of uncomfortable noises”. The rate of suicide is the most acute of them. How a society responds to those who suffer lives of quiet desperation is an index of its civility. The challenge in Ireland is not to indulge in inchoate nostalgia about the past but to build caring communities in school, the neighbourhood and workplace. We need to move from concentrating exclusively on our economy to reflecting deeply on our quality of life.