A country outraged

“Accepting that injustice is as much a feature of sport as good fortune is a huge part of being a sportsperson”placeholder image
“Accepting that injustice is as much a feature of sport as good fortune is a huge part of being a sportsperson”

Everything now is a crisis, prompting outrage. Health cuts, education cuts, the Government’s handling of the Lisbon Treaty.

“After working ourselves into a frenzy, with Opposition TDs thundering at Government, we now find something else to rage about”

Speaker's Corner

Say he was innocent too; he had nothing to do with gangland crime and was not the intended target. But instead of captaining his club’s rugby team, he had only ever bashed a soccer ball around the overgrown local park in his younger days. Having left school after his Junior Cert, he had struggled to hold down a job. Easily led, he joined others in pilfering from local shops now and again. He had a couple of convictions for theft, and a handful for public order offences too.

How much outrage would the nation have mustered if he had met that brutal gunman’s bullet? Somehow ‘Petty criminal shot by mistake’ wouldn’t have been as captivating a headline as ‘Rugby captain gunned down in cold blood’.

Shane Geoghegan didn’t ask to be lionised in death. During his busy 28-year life, he hardly had any aspirations to be held up as a hero. But in a split second last Sunday night week, through no action on his own part, his image changed forever. Henceforth, he will always be a symbol of middle-class, clean-living decency cut down in its prime by an attack on our democracy.

His family didn’t court the public eulogising Shane’s death drew, any more than he lived his life hoping for it. They were innocents too, hurled into a nightmare from which there was no relief last week, even temporarily. Everywhere they went, they were met by their son’s face and his name, as the country railed against the murder of an innocent model citizen.

Shane Geoghegan was, no doubt, blessed with all the virtues attributed to him by those who knew him personally. That he met such a violent death was appalling – and it should not have happened.

But was his death more of an outrage than that of any other murder victim? What about the numerous women who die at the hands of violent husbands? Where’s our sense of outrage about that? Where’s the rush to have those men of violence interned?

What about the homeless people who have met violent deaths on the street? Or the men and women killed by siblings and best friends in drunken rages? What about the gangland criminals themselves? Have we decided that murder is an acceptable end for them? It is bad enough that we are classist about our evaluations of people’s worth – and most of us are – but another matter for us to decide that some human lives are worthless entirely. If we decide that then the criminals truly have won the war: they have forced the rest of us down to their barbaric level where morals don’t matter once hatred takes hold.

We should never lose our sense of outrage at appalling happenings, but nor should we allow its meaning to be lost by through constant use. Everything now is a crisis, prompting outrage. Health cuts, education cuts, gangland crime, the Government’s handling of the Lisbon Treaty. The trouble is that, after the country has worked itself up into a frenzy and the Opposition TDs have thundered and roared at the Government in the Dáil, we all quickly find something else to be outraged about. Some other person or group that we deem a worthy victim. And last week’s victim is forgotten.

Of course a victim’s family and friends are devastated when a loved-one is murdered, and their anger and outrage – no matter how irrational – is understandable. But it behoves the rest of us to take a step back. Wading in with round-them-up-and-shoot-them suggestions – populist and rousing though they may be – is not helpful.

Some problems require solutions that take time to formulate. Barracking the Government into producing a quick-fix solution to every problem will only leave us with more problems. Because the measures they come up with under pressure won’t necessarily be the best ones; they will, more often than not, be the ones they believe people want.

And in the meantime, dozens more Shane Geoghegans will be killed, along with hundreds more innocents whose names we’ll never hear.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice